General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsYes! Stephen Miller was disowned by Duke alumni.
Open Letter to Stephen Miller
To Stephen Miller, Duke University Class of 2007,
Our classs upcoming ten-year reunion serves as an occasion to reflect on how much has changed since we left campus. After graduation, some of us remained in Durham and some of us moved to Dar es Salaam. Some embarked on medical school and some started novels. We can now be found in every type of professional field in every corner of the globebut no matter who or where we are, weve striven to embody the ideals instilled in us by our Duke education.
You have also accomplished much. As a Senior Advisor to President Donald J. Trump, you have ascended to the very peak of American policy-making and have gained the power to influence not just hundreds of millions of Americans, but the lives of people around the world. And yet we find it impossible to see in your words and actions any glimmer of the university values we so cherish, nor the slightest suggestion that you spent four of your most formative years at the same dynamic, diverse institution of higher education we did.
Surely you lived, as we did, in the same Duke quads as migrants and refugees, people who came to our school after childhoods of horrific hardship, people who sought American shores for the promise of safety and opportunity their native homes could not deliver. How is it, then, that as a global refugee crisis continues to unfold you can play such a central role in the executive order banning innocent refugees and the citizens of seven majority Muslim countries?
Surely you had classes where young women were the leading lights of seminars and discussions, women who have now gone on to achieve success in the law, in business, in academia, in the arts, in medicine, in politics. How, then, can you contribute to an administration that overlooks women for cabinet posts, advisory roles, and judgeships, that speaks and acts as though women lack sufficient agency to make decisions about their own families and bodies?
Surely you rode the campus bus with members of the LGBTQ community, some of whom were proudly public, others of whom remained in the closet due to fear and stigma, all of whom were entitled to the same basic protections you were, not to mention dignity and happiness. So how is it that you are contributing to an agenda that seeks to strengthen stigma, undercut protections, and abridge rights?
Surely you ate lunch alongside students of color, people from all manner of socioeconomic backgrounds and locales. How, then, can you condone rhetoric that reduces African Americans to people who hail only from crime-infested, drug-ridden neighborhoods and that insults Hispanics by asking them to support the construction of that most divisive of political symbolsa wall separating them from their heritages, and often their families?
Surely as a columnist for the Duke Chronicle you saw the invaluable benefits of a rigorous, open-minded newsroom, just as you saw how integral the student press was to promoting free, vigorous discourse on campus. So how is it that you can now help lead an administration that seeks to bully and muzzle the press, that views journalists as good for nothing more than serving as mouthpieces for your political agenda?
We, the undersigned members of Dukes Class of 2007 and beyond, see nothing in your actions that furthers the values of intellectual honesty, tolerance, diversity, and respect that we seek to promote in the world. But you can rest assured we will continue to champion those very values and serve as representatives of the Duke we want the world to seefor the next ten years and for the decades to follow.
(3,454 signatures)
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSf9JDRbGYhkAEMJ3hFlypzanVEi9lFEYQfDXD1XX3g_3RInDw/viewform
Link to tweet
Scurrilous
(38,687 posts)K&R
Bleacher Creature
(11,258 posts)ProudLib72
(17,984 posts)Very low chance of it happening, though. Maybe start a petition?
https://www.usnews.com/education/best-global-universities/articles/2012/05/02/10-high-profile-people-whose-degrees-were-revoked
ornotna
(10,810 posts)One can still dream though.
ProudLib72
(17,984 posts)I just wish they would take away degrees based on what people did after receiving them as well. Did you read that part about Gaddafi's son?
BigmanPigman
(51,660 posts)They touched on ALL the different issues that The Nazi despises. Whoever wrote that gets an A+!
ehrnst
(32,640 posts)Raster
(20,998 posts)Bravo, I say!
getagrip_already
(14,970 posts)Don't know if they will bother defending miller (hopefully he is a joke even to them), but they now have a list of names to torture and torment.
These bots are the lowest form of villany on the planet.
But I applaud the Duke Alums for this effort. I certainly would also sign on if I had attended there.
Norbert10
(61 posts)gopiscrap
(23,768 posts)greed, power and money
Gothmog
(145,903 posts)Trump was too stupid to get into the graduate school program at Wharton. In addition, trump did not graduate with honors. http://fortune.com/2015/08/14/donald-trump-wharton/
His school posted his graduate program that shows that he did not graduate with honor shttp://www.pennlive.com/news/2017/02/what_is_trumps_real_record_at.html
shanny
(6,709 posts)Smartest guy ever. Most brains....can't think where I heard that.
Gothmog
(145,903 posts)shanny
(6,709 posts)And I meant to imply that I heard that from der fluegelheinie himself so of course I didn't believe it.
louis-t
(23,313 posts)lastlib
(23,377 posts)louis-t
(23,313 posts)on his ass.
gopiscrap
(23,768 posts)Sophia4
(3,515 posts)Which makes it all the more shocking that Stephen Miller is its graduate.
Horrors!
gopiscrap
(23,768 posts)IronLionZion
(45,652 posts)Stephen Miller probably views this as an honor and loves it when people are against him
calimary
(81,605 posts)Too much education isnt necessarily a good thing. After all, the more highly-educated one is, the more likely that individual will vote for liberals.
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)Thanks for posting, Kpete.
louis-t
(23,313 posts)3,454 signatures!
heaven05
(18,124 posts)Of a bigot, racist, sexist trump puppy, spell that lapdog.....+++1000000
JustABozoOnThisBus
(23,383 posts)Way too long. Too many words. Big words, too. Sad.
OldManTarHeel
(435 posts)Not a fan of Stephen Miller . . . or KoachK for that matter. I do appreciate that letter to Miller tho . .
GO HEELS . . . !
world wide wally
(21,760 posts)RhodeIslandOne
(5,042 posts)So no, that's not happening.
world wide wally
(21,760 posts)But I did gain respect for the students
RhodeIslandOne
(5,042 posts)....if anyone asks for a cite.
It was was not well received from what I gathered.
DemoTex
(25,407 posts)How sweet it is!
Cha
(298,049 posts)Paladin
(28,286 posts)uppityperson
(115,681 posts)CousinIT
(9,274 posts)That notion was shared by one of the letter's signees, Steven Davidson, Trinity '15. Pushing back on some conservative rhetoric about universities, Davidson said, "experiencing four years at Duke is not some liberal brainwashing experience," but is instead a place to expose students to a diversity of experiences and lifestyles.
"That's the fundamental rock of a college experience, and I honestly wonder what he spent his four years at Duke doing," Davidson said. "Did he interact with these people?"
Knight noted that she had been speaking with other Duke alums from her year about Miller when she came across a Facebook post from Sobel expressing similar sentiments. She reached out to him, and they decided to create the open letter.
Much of the letters circulation has been through word of mouth, she explained, adding that she has been encouraging alums to share it on their personal Facebook and Twitter accounts. Next week, she plans to reach out to Duke alumni associations for their help.
There is no formal way for Knight and Sobel to verify that the signatories are Duke alums, but they are requiring alums to submit their email addresses. Alums can also send questions or additional thoughts to openlettertostephenmiller@gmail.com.
The two said they hope the letter received enough attention that it would be difficult for Miller to miss, although they are unsure whether it will impact his views directly.
I think that his actions indicate a close-mindedness to criticism and a resistance to any worldview that doesnt align very much with his, Sobel said.
Davidson acknowledged that the letter was not going to lead Miller to a "change of heart," but argued that at the very least, it clearly states the values of the Duke community. Sobel noted that several Harvard alums organized a similar letter aimed at Jared Kushner, Trumps son-in-law and another one of his senior advisors.
saidsimplesimon
(7,888 posts)Unprofessional, arrogant and dangerous to our democracy. imo