Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

KelleyKramer

(9,011 posts)
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 03:25 AM Jan 2018

The HA false alarm caused by hitting the wrong button excuse is total bullsh*t, and here is why ....


On my computer (actually every computer I have ever owned) if I accidentally hit the delete button for a file, any file... there is a follow up confirmation. Usually a pop up box that says ....

"This will delete the file, ARE YOU SURE?"

That follow up is for any file, even a crummy little text file..

And they don't have any follow up or confirmation for a nuclear attack alert button?

Really?

And even if someone did believe something that stupid and crazy...

We have been under threat of nuke attack for well over 50 years. You would also have to believe that no one, anywhere, at any US facility, in 50+ years has EVER accidentally hit the alert button

And if this excuse is true, then that makes this even worse. Instead of firing whoever made the mistake, they should just be reprimanded. And then everyone involved in approving this systems planning and set-up should be fired.

So if we are to believe this bullshit excuse ....

That puts the problem much higher up the food chain


.

42 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The HA false alarm caused by hitting the wrong button excuse is total bullsh*t, and here is why .... (Original Post) KelleyKramer Jan 2018 OP
Keep in mind the US nuclear arsenal uses floppy disks. Its archaicness applegrove Jan 2018 #1
They also use proprietary operating systems, and hardware, that only DoD/Military has. TheBlackAdder Jan 2018 #34
Not. mahina Jan 2018 #2
Is it possible the alert was made on purpose, by someone intent on graphically illustrating. . . Journeyman Jan 2018 #3
Mahina... Hekate Jan 2018 #4
Hugs sister. mahina Jan 2018 #7
Thanks for the link and pointing out that alarms Hortensis Jan 2018 #22
Were there not also scrolling messages across TV screens in Hawaii about the alert? Rollo Jan 2018 #5
Yes, the alert went out over TV's... Rollo Jan 2018 #6
I sure didnt see that and neither did friends or Fam. mahina Jan 2018 #8
Every Siren in the State of Hawaii Went Off KelleyKramer Jan 2018 #11
Did you bother reading the entire thread...? regnaD kciN Jan 2018 #14
no sirens per my family near Kaneohe Marine Base. flygal Jan 2018 #17
Not at all true. Sorry but this is getting silly. mahina Jan 2018 #32
Vern Miyagi stated that there was a confirmation dialog, and the employee selected 'Yes'. BzaDem Jan 2018 #9
Really? Do you have a link for that? KelleyKramer Jan 2018 #10
Reuters: muriel_volestrangler Jan 2018 #12
"Accident" and "mistake" are ambiguous. Igel Jan 2018 #24
Yes. BzaDem Jan 2018 #13
Do you have a link for your "theory"? Bradshaw3 Jan 2018 #30
I've watched countless co-workers blast right through those messages and choose the wrong option. NutmegYankee Jan 2018 #15
HI not HA Squinch Jan 2018 #16
Thank you. mahina Jan 2018 #33
Yes it was a huge mistake, but let's look at the bright side... Rollo Jan 2018 #18
Alll you are saying is TRUE, however, Ferrets are Cool Jan 2018 #29
Of course, it must have been a horrible experience for those who received the warning... Rollo Jan 2018 #40
At the same time, maybe it's a good thing that people get a taste of what it's going.... Rollo Jan 2018 #42
Also on the bright side: they know a problem exists and will fix it mainer Jan 2018 #36
And why did it take so long to say it was a false alarm? Tipperary Jan 2018 #19
Half hour on a weekend at a shift change? Loki Liesmith Jan 2018 #26
Apparently they felt they had to get permission from the federal government before issuing a retract Rollo Jan 2018 #41
You are mistaken localroger Jan 2018 #20
The report was that the employee was asked for confirmation. Igel Jan 2018 #25
When they exist, it's very common for operators to ack those dialogs without reading localroger Jan 2018 #27
So, I don't know how that works on the computer but.. Stellar Jan 2018 #21
So the governor of HI is lying? former9thward Jan 2018 #28
Now that the facts are known, onenote Jan 2018 #23
There are a lot of crappy interfaces out there... ThoughtCriminal Jan 2018 #31
"Let's play Global Thermonuclear War" Persondem Jan 2018 #35
Must-watch video of Hawaiian official taking responsibility mainer Jan 2018 #37
Thank you. mahina Jan 2018 #39
Seems to be mild reaction, compared with Orson Welles broadcast of "War of the Worlds" in 1938 FarCenter Jan 2018 #38

applegrove

(118,909 posts)
1. Keep in mind the US nuclear arsenal uses floppy disks. Its archaicness
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 03:59 AM
Jan 2018

keeps it from being infiltrated. Maybe the ballistic missile warning system is older too.

TheBlackAdder

(28,253 posts)
34. They also use proprietary operating systems, and hardware, that only DoD/Military has.
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 12:42 PM
Jan 2018

No external connections to the internet. Completely stand-alone to prevent intrusion.

mahina

(17,752 posts)
2. Not.
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 04:08 AM
Jan 2018

We’ve all been affected.

There have not been cell phone alerts for 50 years. That’s the system that failed due to human error.

Our sirens didn’t go off. The military confirmed that there was no threat.

Vern Miyagi says that’s what happened. David Ige say that’s what happened.

http://m.hawaiinewsnow.com/hawaiinewsnow/db_330510/contentdetail.htm?contentguid=DDW6U3Na

Unless you’re here and you know more than our own do I don’t see the point of speculation and dramas.

Journeyman

(15,044 posts)
3. Is it possible the alert was made on purpose, by someone intent on graphically illustrating. . .
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 04:45 AM
Jan 2018

the dangers we face in a nuclear world lead by a hair-trigger ignoramus. Not saying, just asking, and inquiring from the depths of a large dark ignorance illuminated entirely by my paranoia and the hope that someone might do something to avert our course.


I was in Minot, in '73, during the Yom Kippur War when Kissinger took us to DefCon 3 because Nixon was drunk.

Very few of my friends and family outside the military knew anything about the ramp up to confrontation.

What I learned was simple, and quite eye opening:

"In the nuclear age, the difference between the Home Front and the Front Line is simply a matter of perception: If you know we're at war, you are too."

Ultimately, all we have left is Viktor Frankl's Challenge:

"For the world is in a bad state, but everything will become still worse unless each of us does his best. So let us be alert -- alert in a two-fold sense:

"Since Auschwitz we know what man is capable of. And since Hiroshima we know what is at stake."

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
22. Thanks for the link and pointing out that alarms
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 10:45 AM
Jan 2018

did not go off, a detail I missed. Awful for everybody, but this will have caused serious trauma that continues for some unfortunates, and their families.


Rollo

(2,559 posts)
5. Were there not also scrolling messages across TV screens in Hawaii about the alert?
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 04:55 AM
Jan 2018

At least that's what the news on the mainland said...

Rollo

(2,559 posts)
6. Yes, the alert went out over TV's...
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 05:02 AM
Jan 2018

Not just cell phones...

Residents of Hawaii watching a basketball game were greeted by an ominous message on their screens when an emergency alert notification was sent out claiming a "ballistic missile threat inbound to Hawaii." The alert was a false alarm, according to state leaders and emergency officials.
Source: CNN


http://www.cnn.com/videos/us/2018/01/13/hawaii-basketball-game-false-missile-alert-sot-nr.cnn

mahina

(17,752 posts)
8. I sure didnt see that and neither did friends or Fam.
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 05:06 AM
Jan 2018

But I didn’t turn the tv on. Wasn’t anywhere near one.

My neighbor said at 8:45 after everybody knew it was a false alarm an emergency warning was scrolling but it didn’t say what the emergency was.


For whatever that’s worth.

regnaD kciN

(26,045 posts)
14. Did you bother reading the entire thread...?
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 06:52 AM
Jan 2018

There were several posts from Hawaiian DUers saying that there weren't any sirens in their area. In fact, I've yet to see a single DU member from there reporting that any sirens went off.

BzaDem

(11,142 posts)
9. Vern Miyagi stated that there was a confirmation dialog, and the employee selected 'Yes'.
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 05:26 AM
Jan 2018

The employee probably didn't read the confirmation dialog too carefully, and assumed it was asking for confirmation of the test they intended to initiate.

muriel_volestrangler

(101,412 posts)
12. Reuters:
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 06:49 AM
Jan 2018
Ige said the emergency management agency after the incident ordered a change in its procedures requiring two employees, not just one, to send out such an alert in the future. He said such shift changes occur three times a day every day of the year.

Miyagi, who said Hawaii would have only 12 to 13 minutes of warning in an actual attack, declined to say what action would be taken against the employee. Miyagi said the agency routinely tests its emergency alert system and that employee thought he was conducting a test, not realizing he had transmitted the warning with a two-step process on a computer screen until receiving it on his own cellphone minutes later.

“There is a screen that says, ‘Are you sure you want to do this?'” Miyagi said, adding that the employee “feels terrible about it.”

Miyagi, who took responsibility for the incident, said the mistake “should have been caught.”

https://af.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idAFKBN1F20U8

Igel

(35,387 posts)
24. "Accident" and "mistake" are ambiguous.
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 11:19 AM
Jan 2018

If I click on a button, it might not be the one I wanted to click on. The accident was between what my brain wanted and where it told my hand to position the mouse and when I told my finger to click.

"Oops, I meant to click on 'scan' my drive not 'shred' my drive." The "are you sure?" option allows my brain the time to back up and undo the muscle-related screw-up.

On the other hand, it's also a mistake if I think I want to click on a given button because I misread it, misunderstand it, or simply think it's the right one to click for any other (incorrect) reason. The understanding is in my brain, and when my brain's given the chance a fraction of a second later to undo the mistake, it hasn't concluded there was a mistake to undo. "'Shred' is good in skiing, must be good here, too, and mean something like a 'really thorough, ace scan'." Uh, not.


It's the same split in meaning when somebody's killed by a shooter--a policeman or a civilian--and it's a "mistake." Maybe the person doing the shooting fired by accident or didn't know the gun was off safety. Or maybe the mistake was thinking the person shot was somebody else or doing something else but the trigger was nonetheless pulled entirely on purpose. We see the ambiguity sometimes, and when it's an issue of solidarity or belief or group, we collapse that ambiguity into giving just the convenient option.

BzaDem

(11,142 posts)
13. Yes.
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 06:50 AM
Jan 2018
http://abc30.com/primal-fear-as-people-across-hawaii-get-false-alarm-of-imminent-missile-attack/2941655/

Vern Miyagi of the Hawaii Emergency Management Agency said, "There is a screen that says are you sure you want to do this? One person, human error -- and that button was pushed anyway."

NutmegYankee

(16,207 posts)
15. I've watched countless co-workers blast right through those messages and choose the wrong option.
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 07:02 AM
Jan 2018

They didn't read or understand the message.

Rollo

(2,559 posts)
18. Yes it was a huge mistake, but let's look at the bright side...
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 09:28 AM
Jan 2018

Nobody was injured or killed.

No property was damaged.

Life goes on in Hawaii as before.

Or am I missing something?

Consider the flip side... incoming missiles with no warning... I'd prefer a false alarm...

Ferrets are Cool

(21,116 posts)
29. Alll you are saying is TRUE, however,
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 11:56 AM
Jan 2018

do NOT gloss over the mental effect of thinking you and your family may only have minutes to live. It must have been horrific.

Rollo

(2,559 posts)
40. Of course, it must have been a horrible experience for those who received the warning...
Mon Jan 15, 2018, 04:22 AM
Jan 2018

Like the worst nightmare come true

Rollo

(2,559 posts)
42. At the same time, maybe it's a good thing that people get a taste of what it's going....
Mon Jan 15, 2018, 04:29 AM
Jan 2018

to be like for another three years if Trump stays in office...

mainer

(12,037 posts)
36. Also on the bright side: they know a problem exists and will fix it
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 01:10 PM
Jan 2018

And no one died or was injured while they uncovered the weakness of the system.

Rollo

(2,559 posts)
41. Apparently they felt they had to get permission from the federal government before issuing a retract
Mon Jan 15, 2018, 04:23 AM
Jan 2018

ion

localroger

(3,636 posts)
20. You are mistaken
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 10:06 AM
Jan 2018

Those confirmation dialogs are a feature of DOS and Windows, not computers in general. You may have heard of Linux -- it doesn't have them, and if you are logged in as root you can type rm /* -r and it will happily delete every file on your hard drive without asking if you're sure. This is because Linux is based on UNIX, which was designed for enterprise mainframe systems meant to be operated by trained employees, not home computers being operated by n00bs.

localroger

(3,636 posts)
27. When they exist, it's very common for operators to ack those dialogs without reading
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 11:37 AM
Jan 2018

If such a dialog existed it was most likely a feature of the application, but the reason UNIX doesn't have confirmation dialogs is that operators who use a system all day long and every work day tend to get into the habit of punching buttons by muscle memory anyway. I design industrial control systems and have seen this firsthand. Punching OK is just the next motion you make in the sequence, no thought involved. Even when you tell people it's important to read the message they're about to clear they can't make themselves do it because the hand acts before the mind gives the action any consideration.

Stellar

(5,644 posts)
21. So, I don't know how that works on the computer but..
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 10:29 AM
Jan 2018

I too think it was B.S. because I believe Trump has a way of causing a diversion when he wants to get the topic off himself (shi*hole).
When it was happening, Trump NEVER left Florida or stopped his golf game. It didn't appear to surprise him at all.

onenote

(42,831 posts)
23. Now that the facts are known,
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 11:05 AM
Jan 2018

maybe you should back away from the claim that the explanation for the false alarm is "total bullshit".

Persondem

(1,936 posts)
35. "Let's play Global Thermonuclear War"
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 01:05 PM
Jan 2018

"How about a nice game of chess?"

"No. Let's play Global Thermonuclear War."

"Fine."

mainer

(12,037 posts)
37. Must-watch video of Hawaiian official taking responsibility
Sun Jan 14, 2018, 01:15 PM
Jan 2018

Many people on Twitter are dumbfounded that an official took responsibility for the mistake. The guy actually says "It was MY fault." This is so different from normal US politicians' behavior that Americans are astonished.

I suspect this is the influence of Japanese culture in Hawaii. Taking responsibility for your own mistakes now seems foreign to Americans.

(Oh, and please, no snide comments about the men's aloha shirts. This is normal work wear in banks and businesses in Hawaii.)


Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The HA false alarm caused...