Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
11 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
This immigrant committed a crime, when does he get deported?... (Original Post) HipChick Jan 2019 OP
He's not an immigrant DavidDvorkin Jan 2019 #1
He's an immigrant...working...hired by DC United for last 6 months.. HipChick Jan 2019 #3
That does not make him an immigrant DavidDvorkin Jan 2019 #10
Not a ManU fan I see malaise Jan 2019 #2
Arsenal all the way... HipChick Jan 2019 #4
Funny how they always refer to themselves HipChick Jan 2019 #5
Why? Igel Jan 2019 #7
I have no English team but I have a close cousin in England and one of his sons malaise Jan 2019 #6
Presumably, he'll be deported when he commits a deportable crime onenote Jan 2019 #8
Here legally, no other (known) violations, Igel Jan 2019 #9
He has other violations... HipChick Jan 2019 #11

DavidDvorkin

(19,510 posts)
10. That does not make him an immigrant
Sun Jan 6, 2019, 09:32 PM
Jan 2019

An immigrant is someone who moves to a country intending to live there permanently. Living in a country for the duration of a contract does not constitute immigration.

Igel

(35,390 posts)
7. Why?
Sun Jan 6, 2019, 08:09 PM
Jan 2019

It's how the Americans in Prague in the 1990s referred to themselves. I suspect the Americans picked it up from the British, but it's a good phrase to use. It's also an example as to why synonyms are squirrelly and very rare in actual practice. (People act like we're dripping actual synonyms in English. We're not. Lots of words have meanings that greatly overlap, but they're only near synonyms.)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expatriate is a start.

I'd refer to myself as one were I in Mexico, for example, esp. if I was there on business or unboundedly temporarily. It's less "migrant worker" and more "H1-B visa", but direction of motion matters. I would refer to immigrants to the US as immigrants because of direction. I'm here, home country, from my perspective they're immigrants. The assumption is that they're outsiders wanting to become insiders. If I'm in Mexico, I'm out of my home country, I'm the outsider, but if I don't want to be an insider in Mexico I'd refer myself as an ex-pat. If I wanted to settle in and become Mexican, I'd be an immigrant. Legal status here doesn't matter; what matters is how I view myself.

When referring to British, I think of them as immigrants if they're permanently here, as ex-pats if they're here temporarily but that's largely indirect speech on my part, but still it's a bit because they don't *want* to be American. either way, I use the phrase they use. For retirees, they're here permanently but still make explicit their origins not their destination, their loose attachment to the US, and, well, they'll die soon anyway so "loose attachment" is all they're going to achieve. Their patria is still their country of origin, they're here for convenience or some purpose other than "life". They have no intent to assimilate, either transitively or intransitively. They might want things like a British pub with darts and soccer, but nothing bigger than that. The phrase also sort of has a whiff of "not a large number, overall, but hanging together for certain events or in certain social situations." But I can't imagine an "ex-pat neighborhood". I can imagine a politician trying to serve an ex-pat community, but that wouldn't be the same as the "immigrant" community. Again, the thing about ex-pats is that they're still connected to their homeland, and have not so much in common with people with other homelands.

That precisely summed up the americti hosi v Praze that all the Czechs complained were driving up rents, behaving badly in public, and distorting neighborhoods by having things like an English-language bookstore or an English-language laundromat.

When in Prague, Czechs assumed I was an American ex-pat, and I had to say 'no'. I was there on an exchange program. It had a clear terminus ad quem and that disqualified me, to my mind and theirs, from being an ex-pat.

I also suspect that you have to be English speaking with a large vocabulary to not settle into a kind of English koine. Immigrants have a restricted code, if only because they acquire English later and don't pick up all the near-synonyms an educated native speaker would. Most Brits that moved here were long more educated than the average American and were native speakers.

Most Americans haven't seen the word in actual use, so for them it's just a true synonym for "immigrant". And the entire "ex patria" thing makes no sense to them otherwise.

malaise

(269,292 posts)
6. I have no English team but I have a close cousin in England and one of his sons
Sun Jan 6, 2019, 06:59 PM
Jan 2019

plays for the Asses' (as we call them) juniors. He's good but will never be great.

onenote

(42,831 posts)
8. Presumably, he'll be deported when he commits a deportable crime
Sun Jan 6, 2019, 08:17 PM
Jan 2019

which public intoxication and swearing are not.
I'm guessing you knew that but decided not to mention it.

Igel

(35,390 posts)
9. Here legally, no other (known) violations,
Sun Jan 6, 2019, 08:20 PM
Jan 2019

class 4 misdemeanor. No green card pending that we know of or outstanding visa applications.

Plus he's vouched for.

He won't be like the octogenarian officially deported because he lied on his visa application back in the '50s.

Moreover, most of the more prominent deportations that make the press are people here illegally who might be allowed to wander off except they've been arrested. By committing the misdemeanor while present in the country illegally, they're on the government's hit list. Under Obama, it had to be a serious misdemeanor. For Trump, it's just being here. But if you're arrested for a misdemeanor violation, that puts you actively on the radar screen.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»This immigrant committed ...