Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,472 posts)
Wed May 20, 2020, 01:49 PM May 2020

America Deserves a Skinnier President to Mishandle This Pandemic

https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/america-deserves-a-skinnier-president-to-mishandle-this-pandemic

By Harmony Cox

Since the pandemic began, I’ve watched our president ignore the experts, encourage people to drink bleach, and fail to make even the most basic plan to ensure our country survives this crisis. Like many of you, I’ve come away with only one thought: would it kill this guy just to lose a couple pounds?

Sure, I don’t love that our Commander-in-Beef is openly encouraging armed right-wing conspiracy theorists and bigots to march on state capitals for the right to return to their neighborhood TGIFridays. And maybe it is troubling that our porker of a president is also encouraging the citizens of his country to take an unproven medication that might make their hearts explode. But everybody knows there’s only one thing that it makes sense to REALLY hate about President Trump: He is slightly larger than other people!

(snip)

And sure, I’ve heard here and there that focusing on the president’s weight to criticize him does not make a substantive point about his many failings, and just contributes to stigmatizing fat people. Some have even argued that since Trump commonly uses weight as an insult himself, it seems ironic that people who dislike him would stoop to his rhetorical level just to score some cheap hee-haws at the expense of a marginalized population of people who have repeatedly publicly begged us all to stop doing this.

But I’m not being cruel. It’s just that for me, there is no cognitive dissonance between living my values and giggling like a child at the size of someone else’s body. And if you ask me why that is, I will become absolutely furious, because I’m a good person and — HEY, LOOK OVER THERE AT PRESIDENT FAT-ASS! HONK HONK, WIDE LOAD COMIN’ THROUGH!
35 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
America Deserves a Skinnier President to Mishandle This Pandemic (Original Post) WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 OP
Ugh. And I usually like McSweeneys pieces. Squinch May 2020 #1
What don't you like about it? WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #2
However Nancy chooses to get under his skin is fine with me. Squinch May 2020 #16
Even if the rhetoric hurts marginalized people? WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #17
And how does her pointing out that he is, in fact, morbidly obese Squinch May 2020 #18
Because there is no systemic oppression against German people in the U.S. WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #19
So her stating the fact of his obesity in an appropriate medical context oppresses him? Women are Squinch May 2020 #22
Political rivals commenting on each other's bodies is not an appropriate medical context. WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #23
Yes. We have all noted that you object. Squinch May 2020 #27
... Celerity May 2020 #26
He uses racist rhetoric, too. Should we call him a racial slur? He'd probably really hate it. WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #28
non sequitur Celerity May 2020 #30
People's privilege or lack thereof doesn't go away when they become president. WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #31
profoundly disagree on all points Celerity May 2020 #33
You make a good point about quality of life, and what researchers are finally beginning to WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #35
Mentioning Trump's size in relation to his iemitsu May 2020 #3
I know, it's hard to stop talking about people's bodies. WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #5
This rather overstates the degree to which people who denigrate Trump mr_lebowski May 2020 #4
Interesting, I see it on almost every thread I happen to open about him that includes WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #6
I for sure see his orange color or raccoon eyes or anus mouth called out at least as much mr_lebowski May 2020 #7
"Perhaps for one reason or another every time you see weight-based comments made, it sticks out to WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #15
So you hated Teddy Roosevelt also? Nt USALiberal May 2020 #8
Was Roosevelt heavier than Taft, the president that allegedly got stuck in the WH bath tub? Victor_c3 May 2020 #10
You are correct, I think Taft was the heaviest, thus the worst POTUS! Nt USALiberal May 2020 #12
Lmao. WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #13
We may have a skinnier President to botch the pandemic Vogon_Glory May 2020 #9
Plastic Ken isn't skinny enough, what did I miss? Brainfodder May 2020 #11
Perhaps he'll do some workout videos post de-election. forgotmylogin May 2020 #14
Yeah, sure. whatever. Happy Hoosier May 2020 #20
I think most of the glee surrounding Pelosi's comments ecstatic May 2020 #21
"By the way, what's the point of internalizing comments that are made, not to you, but to the WhiskeyGrinder May 2020 #24
+100000 Celerity May 2020 #25
That last question is weird. Happy Hoosier May 2020 #29
Speaking as a stupid person... Buckeye_Democrat May 2020 #32
lolol Celerity May 2020 #34

Squinch

(51,059 posts)
18. And how does her pointing out that he is, in fact, morbidly obese
Wed May 20, 2020, 10:09 PM
May 2020

concern anyone but him?

People point out the fact that he's German. Does that hurt all German people?

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,472 posts)
19. Because there is no systemic oppression against German people in the U.S.
Wed May 20, 2020, 10:22 PM
May 2020

There is, however, against fat people -- often thinly covered with a nod and a wink and fake concern.

Squinch

(51,059 posts)
22. So her stating the fact of his obesity in an appropriate medical context oppresses him? Women are
Thu May 21, 2020, 06:12 AM
May 2020

systematically oppressed. Someone stating fact that I am a woman does not oppress me.

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,472 posts)
23. Political rivals commenting on each other's bodies is not an appropriate medical context.
Thu May 21, 2020, 08:26 AM
May 2020

I object when leaders help build an atmosphere of acceptance around using immutable traits as some kind of political gotcha, as it makes things much harder for everyday people who have those traits, and affects those in power little to not at all.

Pelosi knew exactly what she was doing, as evidenced by the glee with which people jumped on and doubled down on her comments.

Celerity

(43,621 posts)
26. ...
Thu May 21, 2020, 08:38 AM
May 2020


he IS a fat fuck, and uses fat-shaming as a weapon, so he is fair game

PLUS what Pelosi did was NOT fat shaming








Celerity

(43,621 posts)
30. non sequitur
Thu May 21, 2020, 09:14 AM
May 2020

racism implies some endemic power advantage that the purveyor has over the target

Rump is the literal embodiment of power in the US, a rich (supposedly) old white male who holds the most powerful office on the planet

and I absolutely do not concede to your entire framing

it is at heart, a fail, an attempt to try and drag your personal issues into a discussion and make it universal

Pelosi did NOT fat shame, she simply stated a fact, morbidly obese people are at risk for a plethora of health issues

also, I am a thorough believer in the old adage of 'live by the sword, die by the sword'

Rump weaponises actual fat shaming on a massive basis, he is a pure hypocrite

he IS a fat fucking piece of shit, sloppy and pathetic in his lifestyle choices, yet tries to call others this as well in a pathetic power-play attempt

this entire colloquy is full of false equivalency, dodgy, contrived outrage, and 'they go low, we go high' defeatist tosh

punch back, HARD, or suffer the results of ceding the offensive to the fucker

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,472 posts)
31. People's privilege or lack thereof doesn't go away when they become president.
Thu May 21, 2020, 09:37 AM
May 2020

When Obama was president, his blackness was a hindrance in a racist culture. A culture that hates fat people, which American culture certainly does, will hate Trump because he's fat, and focusing on hating him because he's fat perpetuates the culture of hating all fat people simply because they're fat.

it is at heart, a fail, an attempt to try and drag your personal issues into a discussion and make it universal
It's interesting to me how many responses I've gotten telling me this as my "personal issue." Our society's fat-hating culture has repercussions in healthcare, the workforce, our pop and artistic culture, and our political discourse.

Pelosi did NOT fat shame, she simply stated a fact, morbidly obese people are at risk for a plethora of health issues
Size is not an indicator of health, and stating facts under the guise of "concern" is a great way to dog-whistle, as evidenced by the fat-hating reactions her comments have gotten.

Rump weaponises actual fat shaming on a massive basis, he is a pure hypocrite
You can't "weaponize" fat-shaming. Fat-shaming is a weapon. Hypocrites don't care that they're hypocrites.

he IS a fat fucking piece of shit, sloppy and pathetic in his lifestyle choices,
Trump is never going to see how you describe a fat person, but your fat friends and allies might.

this entire colloquy is full of false equivalency, dodgy, contrived outrage, and 'they go low, we go high' defeatist tosh punch back, HARD, or suffer the results of ceding the offensive to the fucker
What "results" are those? What ground do you gain by holding onto fatphobic attacks, and why is it so hard to let them go? As a strongman who is obsessed with beautiful women, a homophobic slur would certainly go low against him. Why not use that as well in your rhetoric?



Celerity

(43,621 posts)
33. profoundly disagree on all points
Thu May 21, 2020, 10:05 AM
May 2020

so much projection and obfuscation

especially the ludicrous

Size is not an indicator of health


keep on thinking that, it is delusional at a certain point, it really is, you hit a certain weight and it has massive, systemic deleterious health effects

Obese and especially morbidly obese people are far more likely to die at a premature age overall than someone who is within a certain healthier range of BMI, even when other variables are take into consideration. If you think that is bollocks, then you are simply in denial of the entire corpus of human bio-science.

Also, the quality of life goes down once you hit certain weights as well, it is gaslighting to say most 300, 325+ pounders (especially shorter ones) are fit and enjoy a truly full range of life activities, although if you are extremely tall and/or an athlete, there are exceptions (far far from the rule overall though, as the average person is neither 6 feet 6+ or so nor a pro/university level athlete)


we are done here, or at least I am


cheers anyway

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,472 posts)
35. You make a good point about quality of life, and what researchers are finally beginning to
Thu May 21, 2020, 10:23 AM
May 2020

understand is that habits matter more than size. Studies have found that anywhere from 30 to 75% of people who meet the definition of "obese" are metabolically healthy. A recent study found that unfit lean people were twice as likely to get diabetes as fit fat people. But our healthcare system and our culture love to attach moral worth to size, and make it a personal problem that's fixable and worth mocking, and that hurts everyone.

Thanks for sticking with me through the discussion.

Info taken from this article.

iemitsu

(3,888 posts)
3. Mentioning Trump's size in relation to his
Wed May 20, 2020, 01:58 PM
May 2020

taking a drug that is not cleared for use against Covid is not fat shaming. It is mentioning a health risk he is also deals with while encouraging others to engage in risky behavior. It is part of a discussion about whether or not what he claims to be doing is safe.
I agree that calling Trump fat is not useful but mentioning a complicating fact that makes what he is encouraging others to do even more unsafe doesn't seem like it should be off limits.

 

mr_lebowski

(33,643 posts)
4. This rather overstates the degree to which people who denigrate Trump
Wed May 20, 2020, 01:59 PM
May 2020

do so on the basis of his weight. I really don't see much of that, relatively.

I do get the point, however. We should be above that, plus there's 1M better reasons to put the guy down.

That much is true.

 

mr_lebowski

(33,643 posts)
7. I for sure see his orange color or raccoon eyes or anus mouth called out at least as much
Wed May 20, 2020, 02:40 PM
May 2020

And anyways, for sure on DU we criticize the guy for all the other things the author names as 'important things' WAY WAY WAY more often and vigorously.

Perhaps for one reason or another every time you see weight-based comments made, it sticks out to you in a way that the deluge of other complaints ... do not?

The gist of this article is that all people are focused on WRT IQ45 is bashing his weight. That's garbage, IMHO.

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,472 posts)
15. "Perhaps for one reason or another every time you see weight-based comments made, it sticks out to
Wed May 20, 2020, 04:28 PM
May 2020
you in a way that the deluge of other complaints ... do not?


Yes, because bigotry looks different than criticism.

The gist of this article is that all people are focused on WRT IQ45 is bashing his weight. That's garbage, IMHO.


Nah, it's just a response to Pelosi's comments and the gleeful celebration of them.

Victor_c3

(3,557 posts)
10. Was Roosevelt heavier than Taft, the president that allegedly got stuck in the WH bath tub?
Wed May 20, 2020, 03:04 PM
May 2020

I guess it never happened, according to the below link, but it makes for a good story.

https://www.history.com/.amp/news/did-william-howard-taft-really-get-stuck-in-a-bathtub

Vogon_Glory

(9,133 posts)
9. We may have a skinnier President to botch the pandemic
Wed May 20, 2020, 02:52 PM
May 2020

Father Pence still looks healthy enough.

====

Seriously, I hope Biden campaign HQ has people making plans for a Biden campaign against Mike Pence in case no. 45 flat-lines.

ecstatic

(32,752 posts)
21. I think most of the glee surrounding Pelosi's comments
Wed May 20, 2020, 10:44 PM
May 2020

was specific to how trump, an extremely thin skinned narcissist, would likely be triggered.

By the way, what's the point of internalizing comments that are made, not to you, but to the absolute worst, most vile American president in modern history?

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,472 posts)
24. "By the way, what's the point of internalizing comments that are made, not to you, but to the
Thu May 21, 2020, 08:28 AM
May 2020
absolute worst, most vile American president in modern history?"


I'm not internalizing them. I'm calling them out as bigotry and object to a leader in my party using bigotry to score a point, when all bigotry does is uphold an oppressive system that hurts everyone.

Happy Hoosier

(7,437 posts)
29. That last question is weird.
Thu May 21, 2020, 08:57 AM
May 2020

There’s no “point” to internalizing such hateful comments. It’s that the message of that is clear: if you are fat, you are worthy of ridicule and disgust. If I don’t insult you, it’s because I am being polite.

Would we ever except such a sorry ass excuse for racial slurs? Or misogynistic rhetoric? No, of course not. It’s like insulting some person by calling them a stupid pol$&, but then telling your polish friend, “oh, I don’t mean YOU.” Too late, we know what you think of Poles.

Buckeye_Democrat

(14,858 posts)
32. Speaking as a stupid person...
Thu May 21, 2020, 09:50 AM
May 2020

... I'm personally offended when Trump is called stupid, accurate or not.

Edit: And the proper term is "moran" anyway.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»America Deserves a Skinni...