Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Tom of Temecula

(1,388 posts)
Wed May 8, 2024, 07:15 AM May 8

Disaster For Trump As Nikki Haley Gets Over 20% Of The GOP Primary Vote In Indiana

Trump had another massive underperformance to a candidate who dropped out months ago. This time Nikki Haley got over 20% of the vote in deep red Indiana. With more than 90% of the votes counted, Trump leads Haley 78.2% t0 21.8%.

Nikki Haley got more than 20% of the vote against Donald Trump after quitting the Republican primary and not spending one single second in the state. Indiana is one of the most Republican friendly states in the nation. There is no way that under normal circumstances a candidate like Haley who dropped out of the race, after Trump clinched the nomination should be getting anything close to 20% of the vote.

There is a segment of the Republican Party that keeps sending the message over and over again in these primaries that they do not want Donald Trump to be their party’s nominee. The polling says that the hush money trial and all of his legal problems don’t hurt Trump with Republicans, but the primary results tell a different story.

Something is harming Trump and causing nearly a quarter of his party to turn against him.There are warning signs flashing all around the Trump campaign that aren’t there for Democrats and Joe Biden. Very simply stated, if Trump loses 20% of Republicans in November to either Biden or Kennedy, he will lose the 2024 presidential election.

https://www.politicususa.com/2024/05/07/disaster-for-trump-as-nikki-haley-gets-over-20-of-the-gop-primary-vote-in-indiana.html

23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Disaster For Trump As Nikki Haley Gets Over 20% Of The GOP Primary Vote In Indiana (Original Post) Tom of Temecula May 8 OP
He will still win Indiana unfortunately. jimfields33 May 8 #1
The math says it could be close tinrobot May 8 #22
irrelevant NoRethugFriends May 8 #2
agreed, and unnecessary NJCher May 8 #12
That has to be good news for Democrats running for office and for Joe. ProudMNDemocrat May 8 #3
JFK jr must be happy Tickle May 8 #4
I think you meant RFK Jr. Wednesdays May 8 #15
Senior moment Tickle May 9 #23
closer to 30% in the burbs. the battleground is the burbs. mopinko May 8 #5
Has he won a majority yet? ColinC May 8 #6
The majority of Haley voters are MAGA through and through LuvLoogie May 8 #7
20% old school Repubs in Indiana is not exactly a shock JCMach1 May 8 #8
Indiana is a partially open primary state radical noodle May 8 #9
More likely in the down races. LiberalFighter May 8 #17
Meh. Every single one of those worthless fuckers will vote for him in November Orrex May 8 #10
To be contrarian in the thread BumRushDaShow May 8 #11
On election note that may be a story to tell. LiberalFighter May 8 #18
If this were happening to Biden, the media would be calling the 2024 election for his opponent already. lees1975 May 8 #13
I've said from the start wryter2000 May 8 #14
Plenty of people didn't expect Obama to win Indiana in 2008 IronLionZion May 8 #16
All he needs to do is demand anyone voting for Nikki Haley LiberalFighter May 8 #19
If he can't get her voters back, he's finished MissMillie May 8 #20
Exactly. lindysalsagal May 8 #21

tinrobot

(10,938 posts)
22. The math says it could be close
Wed May 8, 2024, 06:38 PM
May 8

It was 57/41 in 2020. Subtract out that 20% and TSF is around 45%.

If Biden gets about half of those votes, he could win.

NJCher

(35,934 posts)
12. agreed, and unnecessary
Wed May 8, 2024, 12:10 PM
May 8

I think most DU-ers are politically sophisticated enough to know this is a punch in the gut to his overall support. He doesn't have it and it's only going to get worse, the more court appearances go on.

So who cares if he "wins."

ProudMNDemocrat

(17,036 posts)
3. That has to be good news for Democrats running for office and for Joe.
Wed May 8, 2024, 07:43 AM
May 8

For it appears that the Democrats are getting the message out of what a second term for TSF would mean. For females of child bearing age especially, it has to be downright terrifying.

Tickle

(2,644 posts)
4. JFK jr must be happy
Wed May 8, 2024, 07:58 AM
May 8

I think those folks will head to JFK, which isn't a bad thing.

It's nice knowing that the 3rd party candidate takes away from tRump

mopinko

(70,538 posts)
5. closer to 30% in the burbs. the battleground is the burbs.
Wed May 8, 2024, 08:00 AM
May 8

the real swing voters r suburban woman. ‘soccer moms’. they’ve been deciding elections since w.
joe won on the burb vote.
sick fuck will b CRUSHED.

LuvLoogie

(7,120 posts)
7. The majority of Haley voters are MAGA through and through
Wed May 8, 2024, 09:05 AM
May 8

They are the long view MAGA that are all in on the white fascist hegemony. Most will be there for trump in the general if he makes it that far.

JCMach1

(27,596 posts)
8. 20% old school Repubs in Indiana is not exactly a shock
Wed May 8, 2024, 09:52 AM
May 8

Also, flip back a few years and Obama won Indiana.

They don't always go with the flow.

Weirdly, could be flippable in a 3way race especially

radical noodle

(8,032 posts)
9. Indiana is a partially open primary state
Wed May 8, 2024, 10:06 AM
May 8

If a Democrat wants to tip the scale, they can ask for a Republican ballot and vote in the Republican primary. Voter registration does not have a place for party affiliation. I wonder if that's partly what has happened.



Orrex

(63,340 posts)
10. Meh. Every single one of those worthless fuckers will vote for him in November
Wed May 8, 2024, 10:18 AM
May 8

There are no never-Trumper Republicans. There are only a few who claim to be never-Trumpers.

BumRushDaShow

(130,836 posts)
11. To be contrarian in the thread
Wed May 8, 2024, 10:45 AM
May 8

I won't do a blanket dismissal of the 10% - 20% Haley vote to instead do our own "Butter emails", internalizing the "uncommitted" vote against Biden (that has had a smaller % than the Haley vote against 45).

THAT is the type of thing that is done to continue to promote the narrative of a "'failed' Democratic Party".

The Haley voters are NOT Democrats but they are voters who could leave the top of the ticket blank (with some who might crossover and vote for Biden). Every less vote for 45 (or any GOPer) from the GOP side, although not necessarily helping with the Electoral votes for a red state, CAN help in that state's County/municipal elections (like we just saw happen in a Michigan County Commissioner race with a Commissioner seat flip from red to blue in a deep red county).

lees1975

(3,983 posts)
13. If this were happening to Biden, the media would be calling the 2024 election for his opponent already.
Wed May 8, 2024, 12:32 PM
May 8

It would all be over, nothing to do about it, it shows a decided lack of enthusiasm, blah blah blah. It happens to Trump, blip, nothing. MSNBC gave it a glancing mention.

And here's another thought. If those 21% of Indiana Republicans will go ahead and vote for the orange blob anyway, why bother to go to a meaningless primary and cast a ballot?

I'm with the OP. Even if Trump loses just 10% of those voters, it's enough to flip Indiana, which is usually a reliably Republican state. That's a disaster he cannot afford.

Voter enthusiasm is a huge aspect of the factoring in polling data. If a pollster gets 1,000 responses, and perceives a high level of voter enthusiasm for one of the candidates, that can swing the polling average five percent in either direction. Yet, in many of the polls that are listed in the composite, in spite of an opposition vote of less than 2%, pollsters are saying Biden's support isn't that enthusiastic, and Trump's is. But what we've seen from primary voters--actual people who show up and cast ballots--is more enthusiasm for Biden and less for Trump. Maybe the pollsters need to go over and check with the exit polls where as many as 30% of those voting in Republican primaries are saying they aren't excited about orange blob and won't vote for him if he's convicted.

My prediction, Biden wins the popular vote by 10 million, and carries 27 states with 367 electoral votes.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Disaster For Trump As Nik...