General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsA Week of Gun Violence Does Nothing to Change the N.R.A.’s Message
http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-silence-and-violence-of-the-n-r-aIt is a vision at the heart of the modern gun movement: the more that society makes the threat of violence available to us, the safer we will be. In forty-eight hours this week, the poisonous flaw in that fantasy has been exposed from multiple angles: on Tuesday, two police officers in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, fatally shot a black man, Alton Sterling, while trying to arrest him. Some reports say that, before police arrived, he was openly carrying a gun, which, under the makeshift patchwork of American gun law, would have afforded him more legal protection, not less. Louisiana is one of the forty-five states that allow residents to carry firearms openly in public, and though Sterling was a convicted felon (and therefore probably ineligible to obtain a concealed-carry permit) police could not have known his criminal record before investigating him. It was absurd not to ask whether a white man, exercising his right to open carry, would have been approached differently.
The next day, during a traffic stop in Falcon Heights, Minnesota, a police officer fatally shot a black man, Philando Castile, who, according to his girlfriend, Diamond Reynolds, was licensed to carry a concealed firearm. According to Reynolds, who was in the car and broadcast the aftermath on Facebook, Castile had told the officer that he was carrying his gun, but when Castile reached for his license and registration, he was shot. In the hours that followed, as America turned, once again, to the ritual of mourning the killings of black men by police officers, the N.R.A. was silent. Its official Twitter feed, which often draws attention to cases of police questioning gun owners for exercising the right to carry, said nothing, even as the silence became conspicuous. (@CoolJ90: @NRA care to come to the defense of a man murdered by police who had a license to carry his weapon?)
For critics of the N.R.A., it was an awkward exposure of what is usually left unsaid: the organization is far less active in asserting the Second Amendment rights of black Americans than of white ones.
Igel
(35,393 posts)Seriously, a week of reported hate speech wouldn't cause me to change my views on freedom of speech, hateful sermons wouldn't cause me to question freedom of religion, and even the Mateen shooting didn't cause me to agitate for abolishing the right to due process.
If Trump were to win in the fall, I wouldn't advocate disposing of free elections and a right to vote.
Figure out why people are killing people and work to stop it. Accidents happen, but between suicides and homicides a lot of people decide to pull triggers and send high-momentum bits of lead and steel hurtling through the air. There are things that could be done to help reduce accidents; but if you want to know why the murder rate is so high there are going to be a lot of reasons to try to mitigate. Each on its own is worth dealing with, but that's a hard problem and, well, it makes some victims out to be not entirely blame-free. Emotionally, that's troublesome. Screw emotions.
KamaAina
(78,249 posts)Hope springs eternal.
Skittles
(153,321 posts)fuck them
SwankyXomb
(2,030 posts)Fuck their safety-orange parrots on this site as well.