Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

theaocp

(4,250 posts)
Tue Sep 5, 2017, 12:36 PM Sep 2017

An insight into why joining the D party actually takes some thinking.

I am part of the reason why Democrats have not been successful in the Trump era. I am someone who should be a Democrat, but I’m not. Let me explain.

I was a Republican most of my life — I even worked in the White House for Ronald Reagan. I was very comfortable with the Reagan-era GOP. It was conservative, but not obsessively so, and not at the expense of proper governance. Republicans today easily forget all the “liberal” things Reagan did, such as raising taxes 11 times, giving amnesty to illegal aliens, pulling US troops out of Lebanon, negotiating nuclear disarmament and many other heresies to conservative dogma.

At first, I cheered the Republican takeover of Congress in 1994 and even contemplated going back to work on Capitol Hill. I remember being invited to many meetings with Newt Gingrich and other Republican leaders to help them shape their agenda.
The simplest way to explain my intellectual and political evolution is that I had previously seen the Republican glass as half-full, now I saw it as half-empty.

But soon, I was disturbed by things I saw the new majority doing in Congress. One of the first was slashing some 3,000 staff slots from the congressional committees. I thought this was very unwise because committee staff were the primary source of policy expertise. “Without staff to do the work, how were Republicans going to implement their agenda competently?” I thought.

Read more: http://billmoyers.com/story/im-not-democrat/

4 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
An insight into why joining the D party actually takes some thinking. (Original Post) theaocp Sep 2017 OP
LOL he's waiting for the Democrats to become the old GOP leftstreet Sep 2017 #1
I call major bull frazzled Sep 2017 #2
may i ask who you voted for clu Sep 2017 #3
I always vote D. No worries. lol n/t theaocp Sep 2017 #4

leftstreet

(36,119 posts)
1. LOL he's waiting for the Democrats to become the old GOP
Tue Sep 5, 2017, 12:49 PM
Sep 2017
Anyway, for the time being, I will remain an independent who is waiting for a tough, muscular Democrat with the courage of their convictions and no fear of Republicans to arise, as French President Emmanuel Macron did. He showed that being a moderate does not mean being weak, and that fear of the right is the right’s greatest strength, but one that is easily punctured.


LOL Macron's poll numbers are almost as bad as Trump's

Centrism is dead Mr. Bartlett

frazzled

(18,402 posts)
2. I call major bull
Tue Sep 5, 2017, 12:55 PM
Sep 2017

• "You’d think this would make me a prime candidate for recruitment by the Democrats. But I’m not. First, no Democrat has ever reached out to me."

If you've only been a registered Republican your whole life and are now are an Independent who has not voted in a Democratic primary in the past few cycles, of course no one is going to "reach out to you." If you're such an experienced political operative, you'd know that when campaigns begin to organize, they take their lists for phone calling, door knocking, and emailing from state and local lists of registered Democrats or Independents who have shown interest in the Democratic Party by voting in Democratic primaries in recent years. That's how it works, and it's a principle of effective electioneering that you don't waste precious time and resources on people who disagree with you to begin with. ... It's why I've never been contacted by a Republican. They do that too. All you have to do is send $10 to the state or national party, or even a Democratic candidate, and you'll probably get contacted in the future. More reliably, vote in a Democratic primary. Even if you voted for Hillary Clinton in the general, no one knows that--it's secret. You'll definitely get contacted. Better yet, stop whining and reach out to a Democrat.

• "Of much more importance in terms of my reluctance to join the Democratic Party is that the party doesn’t really seem to stand for anything other than opposition to the GOP ... the Democrats also need a positive agenda of their own."

Oh, just bull. You're not listening if you think this. It's just an excuse. Read any Democratic Party candidate's website on where they stand on the issues; read the Democratic Party Platform; listen to members of Congress. Sure, right now, at this critical moment, we're working to stave off the worst depredations of the Trump administration and Republican Congress. Someone's got to do it—to protect what we "stand for." (See, you can read between the lines.) But we're trying our best to introduce legislation (always blocked by the Republican majority); and every member of Congress puts forth issue statements on where they stand. So, just bull.

I could go on. But here's the thing. It's not that hard: if the Republicans are so reprehensible to you, you need to man (or woman) up and make a choice. You don't need to join the party. But you need to work for their (well-stated) objectives and vote for them.

PS: Also, stop venerating Ronald Reagan. He wasn't all that.



Latest Discussions»General Discussion»An insight into why joini...