Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Judi Lynn

(160,649 posts)
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 05:52 AM Apr 2015

Yoga is secular, does not violate religious freedoms; rules US court

Source: India Today

Yoga is secular, does not violate religious freedoms; rules US court
IndiaToday.in New Delhi, April 4, 2015 | UPDATED 15:05 IST

A California appeals court has allowed yoga to be continued in elementary schools and ruled that yoga taught in elementary schools is not a gateway to Hinduism and does not violate religious freedoms.

"We conclude that the programme is secular and does not have the primary effect of advancing or inhibiting religion, and does not excessively entangle the school district in religion," the three-member appeals court ruled Friday.

The decision by California's 4th District Court of Appeal upheld a lower-court ruling in support of the Encinitas Union Elementary School District in San Diego, IANS reported quoting utsandiego.com.

The school had been sued by parents who argued the school yoga programme was inherently spiritual and therefore unconstitutional.


Read more: http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/yoga-in-school-secular-religious-freedom-california-appeals-court/1/428427.html

66 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Yoga is secular, does not violate religious freedoms; rules US court (Original Post) Judi Lynn Apr 2015 OP
OMG, they're teaching the kids empathy! LuvNewcastle Apr 2015 #1
"Religious Freedoms"!!!1111 "I'm not secure enough in my own religion to allow anyone their Cha Apr 2015 #3
That's pretty much 2naSalit Apr 2015 #51
and how to calm oneself, exercise and improve balance/posture! Terrible! wordpix Apr 2015 #25
They need to be good Capitalists like Jesus was. Oneironaut Apr 2015 #62
Well that's good.. I tried to tell a couple of my friend something like that who dropped out Cha Apr 2015 #2
Having it suggested to you to say "Hamaste" a couple of times in a yoga class you can leave at any time is scary Satanic stuff. Fred Sanders Apr 2015 #8
It does beat all.. Yoga is actually helping the kids but these guys want it over because.. "freedom" Cha Apr 2015 #10
Namaste is not religious cosmicone Apr 2015 #20
Wasn't clear to me whether the parents who sued were religious or atheist goldent Apr 2015 #16
Right. If you had to bet your life on one or the other, which would you choose? valerief Apr 2015 #24
Might I suggest a yoga class for them so they justhanginon Apr 2015 #28
Yes, but had they that much sense, they'd never have sued to begin with. valerief Apr 2015 #46
Is there a specifically Christian sport or physical activity that could mahina Apr 2015 #42
I'm all for letting the lions loose in the coliseum. valerief Apr 2015 #47
There have been a lot of FFRF lawsuits recently, so that is what I would have guessed. goldent Apr 2015 #52
I thought FFR was written into the Constitution's First Amendment. valerief Apr 2015 #53
Yeah, I think that is what FFRF lawsuits are based upon goldent Apr 2015 #54
They're probably scared of the fire... Blue_Tires Apr 2015 #65
I don't think you understand where this is coming from... glowing Apr 2015 #4
I think they just see yoga pants as the work of the Devil....offends their Puritan morals. Fred Sanders Apr 2015 #12
No, I'm telling you there is this long crazy town link to Hinduism thru Yoga poses/ glowing Apr 2015 #13
Which is strange because Hinduism's worship of craven idols is the closest thing there is to Catholicism. Fred Sanders Apr 2015 #14
I actually work for a couple who is Hindu...AND yes, their ceremonies remind me a lot of the glowing Apr 2015 #18
what type of closed minded hatred are you preaching????? monkeyofstick Apr 2015 #66
It's a thin line elias7 Apr 2015 #5
Its essentially sun salutations, downward dog.. Its used to increase flexablity for the kids. glowing Apr 2015 #19
Yoga predates Sikhism by thousands of years. cosmicone Apr 2015 #21
That it does, elias7 Apr 2015 #60
Unfortunately, the yoga taught in the West focuses on the poses cosmicone Apr 2015 #61
WHAT ABOUT THOSE EAST ASIAN SELF DEFENSE SCHOOLS? cynzke Apr 2015 #6
Well, about that... Bradical79 Apr 2015 #17
Well, that went down hill fast Telcontar Apr 2015 #43
May The Force Be With You, LOL! cynzke Apr 2015 #44
Yay San Diego! nt bananas Apr 2015 #7
Wait until they find out the Hindus gave us zero jberryhill Apr 2015 #9
Or that English derives from ancient Indian Sanskrit....of course they will just not believe it. Fred Sanders Apr 2015 #11
A friend of mine got into yoga TlalocW Apr 2015 #15
I'm surprised the RW self-identified christians haven't tried to outlaw soccer in schools yet. nt Zorra Apr 2015 #22
The suing fuckheads probably LOVE brain-damaging football, though. valerief Apr 2015 #23
and WWE porn fake wrestling wordpix Apr 2015 #27
Sidenote on soccer and brain damage: Arugula Latte Apr 2015 #49
Soccer, football--it's all football to me. nt valerief Apr 2015 #50
Any sport where head contact (to other players or to the ground) is possible goldent Apr 2015 #56
well, super- rather than preternatural then! but yes we've seen the fundies running MisterP Apr 2015 #26
Thanks for sharing the link. Would have missed it altogether. n/t Judi Lynn Apr 2015 #35
Torquemada Syndrome orpupilofnature57 Apr 2015 #29
Some knucklehead actually brought this suit? onecaliberal Apr 2015 #30
P.E is just as good as Yoga. Quasimodem Apr 2015 #31
They are talking about hatha yoga, right? Larry Engels Apr 2015 #32
and a hatha practitioner might well say it's religious--as religious as preparing ghee MisterP Apr 2015 #36
Yes. Larry Engels Apr 2015 #38
oh, the fundies won't be happy until sitting down is banned unless you're married MisterP Apr 2015 #39
Don't give them ideas. n/t Chan790 Apr 2015 #48
It's not even hatha yoga, just some stretching exercises from hatha yoga bananas Apr 2015 #41
They were really careful to secularize it. Larry Engels Apr 2015 #45
Christian dominionists/reconstructionists hate everything and everybody. blkmusclmachine Apr 2015 #33
oh no! next they will be teaching our little angels how to hopemountain Apr 2015 #34
Dinner forks should be outlawed immediately nolabels Apr 2015 #63
like this dembotoz Apr 2015 #37
The original 2013 ruling: "Yoga is a religious practice, but not the way that it is taught by..." bananas Apr 2015 #40
I think the courts just have to use some common sense on these cases goldent Apr 2015 #55
Yoga - the little green guy? I thought he believed in the force. 24601 Apr 2015 #57
"gateway to Hinduism" - who says stuff like that? Matariki Apr 2015 #58
"Gateway" has a nasty connotation because of "gateway drugs." Larry Engels Apr 2015 #64
It is and it isn't - can be part of a spiritual practice but doesnt have to be - like meditation can Kashkakat v.2.0 Apr 2015 #59

LuvNewcastle

(16,860 posts)
1. OMG, they're teaching the kids empathy!
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 06:34 AM
Apr 2015

Obviously, yoga is going to teach those poor kids to be socialist vegetarians. Time to home school them so they'll be ignorant sociopaths like good Americans are supposed to be.

Cha

(297,818 posts)
3. "Religious Freedoms"!!!1111 "I'm not secure enough in my own religion to allow anyone their
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 06:46 AM
Apr 2015
Freedom!"

wordpix

(18,652 posts)
25. and how to calm oneself, exercise and improve balance/posture! Terrible!
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 02:26 PM
Apr 2015
What will these awful schools think of next?

Oneironaut

(5,535 posts)
62. They need to be good Capitalists like Jesus was.
Fri Apr 10, 2015, 07:45 AM
Apr 2015

My favorite passage in the Bible was how Jesus kicked that homeless guy in the nuts with Pinkberry in-hand before going back to his job as head CEO of Monsanto.

Cha

(297,818 posts)
2. Well that's good.. I tried to tell a couple of my friend something like that who dropped out
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 06:43 AM
Apr 2015

of Yoga class back in New York because they thought it would be against their religion. Sigh..

Oh, I use to live in Encinitas, CA, too.. quite the health oriented town.. but there always has to be somebody afraid of "religious freedoms"!

I bet it's helping the kids.

Mahalo Judi

Fred Sanders

(23,946 posts)
8. Having it suggested to you to say "Hamaste" a couple of times in a yoga class you can leave at any time is scary Satanic stuff.
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 09:49 AM
Apr 2015

Why are so many Christians so utterly moronic that they take their childish fears of...yoga?... to a court?

Cha

(297,818 posts)
10. It does beat all.. Yoga is actually helping the kids but these guys want it over because.. "freedom"
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 09:53 AM
Apr 2015

valerief

(53,235 posts)
24. Right. If you had to bet your life on one or the other, which would you choose?
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 02:24 PM
Apr 2015

on edit
And here you go. Google is magic.
http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/apr/04/yoga-classes-do-not-violate-students-religious-rights-californian-court-rules

Stephen and Jennifer Sedlock and their two children had brought the lawsuit claiming yoga promoted Hinduism and inhibited Christianity. They were disappointed with the ruling and considering their options.

justhanginon

(3,290 posts)
28. Might I suggest a yoga class for them so they
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 02:49 PM
Apr 2015

can meditate and calm down a bit. Maybe even meet some really nice people outside their regular church going friends. Who knows, it could possibly expand their horizons a tad.

mahina

(17,717 posts)
42. Is there a specifically Christian sport or physical activity that could
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 01:01 AM
Apr 2015

be offered also? Something like Coloseum sprinting or pew kneebends and squats? ?

valerief

(53,235 posts)
53. I thought FFR was written into the Constitution's First Amendment.
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 06:20 PM
Apr 2015
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof

goldent

(1,582 posts)
54. Yeah, I think that is what FFRF lawsuits are based upon
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 06:24 PM
Apr 2015

Of course, the tricky part is to determine what "make no law" means, what "religion" is, what "establishment" is, what "free exercise" is, etc. It keeps the lawyers and judges busy!

 

glowing

(12,233 posts)
4. I don't think you understand where this is coming from...
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 06:47 AM
Apr 2015

There is a series and probably has been updated; that went they the church talking about yoga and meditation being a gateway to Hinduism and then would show writhing people in India and say it's a direct path to hell and demonic possession. It was nutso! And they show these videoed to kids middle school and up to adult in bible studies and youth groups... It's not everywhere by now, but I remeber the videos from the 90's and wanting to either throw up or laugh.

The Pastor would say you need to meditate on the words and scripture and find your place; and because of those videos, half of the kids were freaking out because he used meditate... That's when I realized how indoctrination works on sheep.

 

glowing

(12,233 posts)
13. No, I'm telling you there is this long crazy town link to Hinduism thru Yoga poses/
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 10:04 AM
Apr 2015

Last edited Sat Apr 4, 2015, 10:53 AM - Edit history (1)

Which I should add on edit, I disagree with and have my yoga mat rolled up all nicely at home.. LOL

Fred Sanders

(23,946 posts)
14. Which is strange because Hinduism's worship of craven idols is the closest thing there is to Catholicism.
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 10:06 AM
Apr 2015
 

glowing

(12,233 posts)
18. I actually work for a couple who is Hindu...AND yes, their ceremonies remind me a lot of the
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 11:01 AM
Apr 2015

Catholic Church in "tradition".

Most people in this country are entirely too sheltered from life outside of their little corner of the world. Its not hard to get them to fear what they don't know... Add a couple of scantily clad brown Indian men writhing on the floor, flash a picture or two of Ghandi and his demonstrations as "church worship, have another picture of some man in a "yoga pose" twisted up like a pretzel, and then throw in some old footage of the Beatles... LOL. AND this was a video series we had to watch. It was crazy towns. I guess this was an effort of a church to show that this is the only "true" religion. I wouldn't doubt since 2001, there isn't a whole new series that makes Islam the devils spawn as well.

You know where I went to church, just a small town in Vermont. So, if the videos and other religious materials made their way to that small church, they made it around to many others. Oh, you would have really gotten a hoot out of the whole "science in the bible" series I was sitting through. I zoned out when the man started explaining how "The Great Flood" occurred and they were on the "cusp of finding Noah's ark".... I started doing my homework and real science studying, and I didn't attend anymore "science lectures". This is how these people believe the shit they are saying.

elias7

(4,030 posts)
5. It's a thin line
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 08:14 AM
Apr 2015

My wife has gotten thoroughly into Kundalini and it is bound up with religious tradition, in this case, Sikhism, to which my wife has coverted and does wear a turban now. I go to classes now and again, and the whole goal is losing one's personal identity and "yoking" one's self or identifying with the universal/infinite/divine/god. As this resonates with my Taoist tradition, I don't mind, but a very strong argument can be made for this being religious and indoctrinating.

I don't know much about other yogic practices, but I have found them thoroughly secular.

 

glowing

(12,233 posts)
19. Its essentially sun salutations, downward dog.. Its used to increase flexablity for the kids.
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 11:17 AM
Apr 2015

My son like doing Yoga poses with me and "showing me" how to do one's he's done in PE class... I live in FL now, there is nothing "religious" about it and if it were, these idiot holy rollers would really freak out down here. As long as its "housewife" approved.. its all good.

elias7

(4,030 posts)
60. That it does,
Thu Apr 9, 2015, 06:07 PM
Apr 2015

But yogic traditions are fundamentally religious insofar one is attempting to "yoke" individual consciousness with universal consciousness. Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism, Taoism, etc are religions of one's identification with god (whatever you want that to symbolize), whereas Judeochristian and Muslim traditions are religions of one's relationship with god. So, yoga for Catholics, for example, would be experiencing the divine "out there", as God is separate from the individual, while the kundalini practitioner is seeking the divine "within", as God and the individual are one.

It gets a little confusing when I think about it too much, but isn't a downward DOG just an upward GOD?

 

cosmicone

(11,014 posts)
61. Unfortunately, the yoga taught in the West focuses on the poses
Thu Apr 9, 2015, 06:26 PM
Apr 2015

and poses are a miniscule part of Yoga.

One goes from Yam, Niyam, Asan (poses), pranayaam (breathing techniques), dhyan, dharana and samadhi. The Kundalini chakra awakening occurs in the dharana phase which is never focused on in the West.

I rarely do the poses but do the breathing and meditation (dhyan) every day.

cynzke

(1,254 posts)
6. WHAT ABOUT THOSE EAST ASIAN SELF DEFENSE SCHOOLS?
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 08:25 AM
Apr 2015

That people send their kids too? They don't seem to worry that the kids are going to gain a religion as well as a black belt!
Duh! People are so stupid in this country. Its mind boggling!

 

Telcontar

(660 posts)
43. Well, that went down hill fast
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 08:06 AM
Apr 2015

Started off intereating enough, then took a turn into crazy town.

Swear to God, I think I'm an atheist.

 

jberryhill

(62,444 posts)
9. Wait until they find out the Hindus gave us zero
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 09:51 AM
Apr 2015

...and the numbers are Arabic.

Math class is a hotbed of indoctrination.

Public schools have no business making people believe things.

Fred Sanders

(23,946 posts)
11. Or that English derives from ancient Indian Sanskrit....of course they will just not believe it.
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 09:54 AM
Apr 2015

Live in a "bungalow"? Sanskrit.

TlalocW

(15,392 posts)
15. A friend of mine got into yoga
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 10:10 AM
Apr 2015

At a time when things weren't going so well in his personal life. I joined him on a few excursions to find a yoga place he liked. At a local Jazzercise, it actually was pretty - if not Hinduist - New Age, with the instructor turning down the lights, playing zitar music, and talking about chakras. I actually fell asleep for a few moments (and probably snored). Then we actually went to a New Age church, and there was none of that, and it was treated by the instructor as a work-out. It's all in how you frame it.

The New Age church was in a repurposed strip mall that housed it, a gay bar next to it, and a Baptist church next to the gay bar, which I thought was funny since this was when I lived in Tulsa.

TlalocW

 

Arugula Latte

(50,566 posts)
49. Sidenote on soccer and brain damage:
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 01:40 PM
Apr 2015

I can't stand American football. We wouldn't let our son play football (and he was always a big athletic kid who got "recruited" a lot).

However, soccer has a VERY high rate of concussions (and usually not from heading the ball either). It's the sport that produces the most concussions for girls.

goldent

(1,582 posts)
56. Any sport where head contact (to other players or to the ground) is possible
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 06:49 PM
Apr 2015

will have some amount of concussions. The good thing is that processes to detect and respond to concussions are mandated in all high school sports (at least in my state). It might be hard to eliminate concussions entirely but not as hard to prevent a student from repeatedly having them.

MisterP

(23,730 posts)
26. well, super- rather than preternatural then! but yes we've seen the fundies running
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 02:27 PM
Apr 2015

around saying India's poor because it's polytheistic and uses integral exercises, or Pat Robertson's video of Haiti after the quake and he zooms in ominously on some Vodun implements as the cause of the misery

they also break up peasant collectives as "Commie creations of de Debbil" in the Third World

(of course there's plenty of other groups panicking about "the occult" being let in)

Quasimodem

(441 posts)
31. P.E is just as good as Yoga.
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 03:25 PM
Apr 2015

"two yoga classes of 30 minutes or more per week. [and] We are seeing tremendous results..."Kids are more flexible, stronger, and have more ability to focus."

Just go back to the Physical Education programs I tool in Elementary and High School back in the fifties and sixties. You'll get the same result, because nothing improves your ability to focus, dodge and move quickly so rapidly as having your nose broke by a soccer ball smashing into your face as hard as your bully of a coach can kick it.

 

Larry Engels

(387 posts)
32. They are talking about hatha yoga, right?
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 03:28 PM
Apr 2015

Other forms of yoga, e.g., raja yoga are clearly religious practices.

MisterP

(23,730 posts)
36. and a hatha practitioner might well say it's religious--as religious as preparing ghee
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 06:04 PM
Apr 2015

I think one of the deeper issues is the view of religion as a dimension to life (I don't mean that you do everything "religiously" like sitting or cooking in a "religious way&quot vs. the view of religion as a compartmentalized thing, as something "attended" an hour every week and then set aside

it's certainly reflecting a cosmogonic vision, rather than just brainless stretches--but when the fundies whine that it's a "doorway" to Hinduism they see religions as basically countries: they send out agents (believers) and can expand only at another's expense, conquering living "territory"

 

Larry Engels

(387 posts)
38. Yes.
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 08:30 PM
Apr 2015

I was told by my hatha yoga teacher that doing hatha yoga is really a preparation for raja yoga. First you relax the body, then the mind. But hatha yoga can be taught and learned without that intent. That secularizes it, right?

MisterP

(23,730 posts)
39. oh, the fundies won't be happy until sitting down is banned unless you're married
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 09:40 PM
Apr 2015

or have a doctor's note https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dancing_ban

I was just pondering the notions of "religious" and "secular" in the larger sense

bananas

(27,509 posts)
41. It's not even hatha yoga, just some stretching exercises from hatha yoga
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 01:00 AM
Apr 2015

See post #40 about the original 2013 ruling: http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1014&pid=1059122

Yoga is a religious practice, but not the way that it is taught by the Encinitas Union School District at its nine campuses, San Diego Superior Court Judge John S. Meyer said in Monday’s ruling.

Meyer said the school district stripped classes of all cultural references including the Sanskrit language. He noted that the lotus position was renamed the “crisscross applesauce” pose.

hopemountain

(3,919 posts)
34. oh no! next they will be teaching our little angels how to
Sat Apr 4, 2015, 04:46 PM
Apr 2015

meditate and satan's gates will open and swallow them hole.

nolabels

(13,133 posts)
63. Dinner forks should be outlawed immediately
Fri Apr 10, 2015, 12:24 PM
Apr 2015

It's an obvious, considering Lucifer himself, has a fork as his trademark

bananas

(27,509 posts)
40. The original 2013 ruling: "Yoga is a religious practice, but not the way that it is taught by..."
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 12:56 AM
Apr 2015
http://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2013/07/01/judge-to-rule-on-whether-yoga-tied-to-religion/

Judge Rules Yoga Not Tied To Religion, Allowed To Remain In Public Schools
July 1, 2013 12:18 PM

SAN DIEGO (AP) — A judge is allowing a San Diego-area school district to teach yoga, rejecting the claims of disgruntled parents who called it an effort to promote Eastern religion.

Yoga is a religious practice, but not the way that it is taught by the Encinitas Union School District at its nine campuses, San Diego Superior Court Judge John S. Meyer said in Monday’s ruling.

Meyer said the school district stripped classes of all cultural references including the Sanskrit language. He noted that the lotus position was renamed the “crisscross applesauce” pose.

The judge said that the opponents of the yoga class were relying on information culled from the Internet and other unreliable sources.

“It’s almost like a trial by Wikipedia, which isn’t what this court does,” Meyer said.

<snip>


goldent

(1,582 posts)
55. I think the courts just have to use some common sense on these cases
Sun Apr 5, 2015, 06:42 PM
Apr 2015

The thought of trial by the Internet is scary, although sometimes we seem to experience something pretty close to that.

 

Larry Engels

(387 posts)
64. "Gateway" has a nasty connotation because of "gateway drugs."
Fri Apr 10, 2015, 01:12 PM
Apr 2015

In fact, I'll bet very few people who do hatha yoga (especially this modified version) go on to other forms of yoga, e.g., raja yoga.

Kashkakat v.2.0

(1,752 posts)
59. It is and it isn't - can be part of a spiritual practice but doesnt have to be - like meditation can
Mon Apr 6, 2015, 07:24 PM
Apr 2015

be prayer. Or it can be just meditation.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Yoga is secular, does not...