Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Judi Lynn

(160,682 posts)
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 10:07 AM Nov 2017

Ohio set to execute inmate Alva Campbell, who needs wedge pillow to help him breathe

Source: NBC News

NOV 15 2017, 8:56 AM ET
by TRACY CONNOR

Ohio plans Wednesday to execute a death row inmate who is so sick that prison officials will provide a wedge-shaped pillow to help him breathe during the lethal injection.

Alva Campbell, 69, was convicted of shooting 18-year-old Charles Dials in cold blood during a carjacking following his 1997 escape from custody on armed robbery charges.

Campbell, who had already served 20 years for an earlier murder, pretended he was paralyzed to stage his getaway. But his lawyers say there is nothing fake about his illnesses now.

"Campbell suffers from lung cancer, COPD, respiratory failure, prostate cancer, hip replacement, and severe pneumonia," they wrote in a petition to the U.S. Supreme Court. "Campbell must take oxygen treatments four times a day in order to function, and he relies on a walker for very limited mobility."

Read more: https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/lethal-injection/ohio-set-execute-inmate-alva-campbell-who-needs-wedge-pillow-n820956

16 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

George II

(67,782 posts)
1. So they're going to keep him breathing so they can vindictively stop him from breathing!
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 10:11 AM
Nov 2017

What have we become?

Botany

(70,654 posts)
2. The man murdered 2 people, shot somebody else, many armed robberies, and a host of ...
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 10:14 AM
Nov 2017

.... other crimes too. I oppose the D.P. but I have zero sympathy for this piece of dirt.

Tommy_Carcetti

(43,230 posts)
9. It's not really about sympathy, though.
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 03:15 PM
Nov 2017

It's about the fact that the death penalty serves no actual legitimate purpose.

 

Egnever

(21,506 posts)
12. Agreed and at this point it will likely be an end to his suffering
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 06:06 PM
Nov 2017

Would likely be much worse for him to let his cancer run its course.

Considering his Crimea I am inclined to let him suffer.

Journeyman

(15,044 posts)
3. Nothing new. Consider Robert Pierce, executed at San Quentin while dying, 1956 . . .
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 11:05 AM
Nov 2017

Better yet, let Evan S. Connell explain. . .

Robert Pierce, awaiting execution at San Quentin prison,
contrived to slash his throat with a shard of glass,
precipitating a frantic quarrel among the authorities:
some insisted that he be executed before he bled to death
while others thought he should be taken to the hospital.
Presently, with gouts of blood bubbling from his neck,
he was carried into the gas chamber. Witnesses screamed,
vomited and several fainted. The decision had been reached,
officials later explained, because at the time of death
the prisoner probably would still be alive and therefore
conscious not only of his crime but of the retributions
justly demanded by the Sovereign State of California.


Evan S. Connell, Points for a Compass Rose

Pierce was a contemporary of Caryl Chessman. They shared the Row together, but not a cell, and not even near each other, as Pierce was too dangerous to be kept with the other condemned prisoners; they kept him penned up in a special section dubbed the "Iron Curtain."

Response to FarPoint (Reply #4)

Response to FarPoint (Reply #6)

marble falls

(57,523 posts)
11. Wait. Don't tell me. You believe that this execution is about justice for dead people ....
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 05:08 PM
Nov 2017

cuz its not. Its about maintaining standards of justice for society. Dead people get no justice, but society gets some in reaffirming rule of law and order of society. This is nothing to do with an eye for an eye but is a measure of our humanity in dealing with members of society who've breached law and custom.

Regardless of whether he's murdered one or 1000 others he's definitely not going to be killing anyone ever again if he's allowed to live out a miserable existence that won't be lasting much longer.

Justice is NOT about revenge it is about bringing about a solution that protects society.

Don't give me that appeal to my emotion about how I might feel if it were my son or daughter he murdered, because that's exactly why family and friends of victims do not get to judge, prosecute or deliver justice. Crimes against us are crimes against society and justice is supposed to be unemotional and in the name of society not my hypothetical dead children. I may not understand it on an emotional level but I certainly have a good grasp of how the system works if its to be fair.

The same result happens either way: he will most definitely die in prison soon without adding to his kill count and that result constitutes justice. Maybe you'd like to confiscate his pillow, too?

Eugene

(61,974 posts)
13. Ohio execution called off after officials fail to find a vein for lethal injection
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 06:14 PM
Nov 2017

Source: The Guardian and the Associated Press

Ohio execution called off after officials fail to find a vein for lethal injection

Guardian staff and Associated Press
Wednesday 15 November 2017 19.19 GMT

Ohio called off the execution of a condemned killer with multiple health problems on Wednesday, because members of the state’s execution team were unable to find a vein to insert an IV that would administer the lethal drugs.

It was only the third time in US history that an execution has been called off after the process had begun.

The execution team first worked on both of Alva Campbell’s arms for about 30 minutes on Wednesday while he was on a gurney in the state’s death chamber and then tried to find a vein in his right leg below the knee.

Members of the execution team used a device with a red flashing light that appeared to be a way of locating veins while also periodically comforting Campbell, patting him on the arm and shoulder.

About 80 minutes after the execution was scheduled to begin, the 69-year-old Campbell shook hands with two guards after it appeared the insertion was successful. About two minutes later, media witnesses were told to leave without being told what was happening.

-snip-


Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/nov/15/ohio-execution-called-off-alva-campbell-vein-lethal-injection

marble falls

(57,523 posts)
16. It gets worse if you read the Alva Cambell's life story and his efforts to try to cooperate ....
Wed Nov 15, 2017, 08:44 PM
Nov 2017

with his own execution:

http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a13607091/ohio-alva-campbell-death-penalty/


Here's as Crazy a Death Penalty Story as You'll Find

The state of Ohio, ladies and gentlemen.
Getty
By Charles P. Pierce
Nov 14, 2017
680

If all goes to plan, and we’ll get to the insanely detailed plan in a moment, the state of Ohio—John Kasich, moderate Republican, governor—will execute a 69-year-old man named Alva Campbell for a 1997 murder that was admittedly heinous, and also was the second time he’d killed somebody. Campbell already was on parole for killing someone when he killed Charles Dials during a carjacking.

Campbell has a galaxy of medical problems. He uses a walker. He is hitched to a colostomy bag. He has chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder, and he takes four breathing meds a day. His lawyers think Campbell may have lung cancer, and in any case, he has so much trouble breathing that Ohio has had to make modifications in its procedures to kill him properly. Hence, the insanely detailed plans we mentioned earlier, courtesy of WCPO-TV in Cincinnati:

Ohio will provide a wedge-shaped pillow to help a condemned inmate breathe as he’s being executed this week, among other accommodations the state is considering. Death row prisoner Alva Campbell, who has said he is too ill for lethal injection, became mildly agitated when officials tried lowering him to a normal execution position, according to a medical review by a physician contractor for the Department of Rehabilitation and Correction.

Then, there is the problem with his veins.

Dr. James McWeeney noted there were no objective findings such as increased pulse rate or breathing to corroborate Campbell’s anxiety. Nevertheless, he recommended allowing Campbell to lie “in a semi-recumbent position” during the execution. The same exam failed to find veins suitable for inserting an IV on either of Campbell’s arms.

(We should note here that Campbell offered to save Ohio all this fuss and bother. He asked to be killed by a firing squad, a method that does not require either wedge-shaped pillows or functioning veins. This seems awfully civic-minded for a convicted murderer. A judge put the kibosh on that, because, in 2015, moderate Republican Governor John Kasich eliminated that option and, thus, it would have required an act of the Ohio legislature to allow the state to kill Alva Campbell by shooting him. The judge didn’t think the legislature could get its act together in time to do that, so here we are.)

"Ohio will provide a wedge-shaped pillow to help a condemned inmate breathe as he’s being executed this week..."

The guy who prosecuted Campbell called him “the poster child” for the death penalty. The prosecutor may be more right than he knows, if any of what Campbell’s lawyers presented on behalf of a plea for clemency is true. According to his attorneys, and as reported by The Columbus Dispatch, Campbell’s childhood could be called Dickensian, if Dickens were reincarnated as Pol Pot.

Campbell was the mixed-race son of a racist, alcoholic father who would make his children watch as he beat their mother bloody and often unconscious, Stebbins said. His father also beat the children and molested Campbell’s sisters and mostly likely molested Campbell as well, Stebbins said. Then, after his father was imprisoned for incest, a 10-year-old Campbell began a journey through state facilities that didn’t protect him. Lighter than 90 percent of boys his age and shorter than 80 percent, Campbell was an easy target for older, bigger boys who beat and raped him, said Bob Stinson, a psychologist who has examined Campbell.

Unbelievably, that’s not the half of it. Sister Helen Prejean, the anti-death penalty activist who was the subject of Dead Man Walking, has been on the electric Twitter machine, sharing what she knows about Campbell’s upbringing. It is downright otherworldly.

Alva's father beat his mother "like he was in the boxing ring" while the children watched. He would throw Alva's mother out of the house in cold weather and threaten to kill the children if they let her back inside…Alva's father also beat Alva and three of his other siblings severely. Only two of Alva's sisters were exempted - one, who suffered from Down Syndrome, and another who has his favorite child….Alva's father subjected his children to sadistic games. He would stick his finger into a live electrical socket and then force the children to join hands with him and feel the electricity course through their tiny bodies.

Logic, folks. The state of Ohio could find no way to give Alva Campbell comfort as a child, but, now that he’s dying, the state of Ohio is doing everything it can to make sure he’s comfortable while the state of Ohio is killing him. We are a Christian nation, after all. There will be a wedge-shaped pillow, so he’ll have no trouble breathing until he can’t anymore.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Ohio set to execute inmat...