In blow to Native Americans, US court approves land swap for Rio's Arizona copper mine
Source: Reuters
March 1, 2024 6:48 PM EST
March 1 (Reuters) - A U.S. appeals court on Friday narrowly ruled that the federal government may give away thousands of acres in Arizona to Rio Tinto (RIO.AX) (RIO.L) for a copper mine, upholding a previous ruling and rejecting an argument from Native Americans that the land should be preserved for its religious and cultural value.
The 6-5 ruling from the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals essentially defers to a 2014 decision made by the U.S. Congress and then-President Barack Obama to give the land to Rio and minority partner BHP (BHP.AX) for the Resolution Copper project.
The decision comes amid the U.S. presidential election season, in which former President Donald Trump, who supports the mine, is likely to face off against President Joe Biden, who narrowly won Arizona in the 2020 election thanks to Native American votes.
The move is the latest blow to the Apache Stronghold, a nonprofit group comprised of the San Carlos Apache tribe and others who have long opposed the mine, which would destroy a site where Indigenous ceremonies have been held for generations but would, if developed, supply more than a quarter of U.S. copper demand for the renewable energy transition.
Read more: https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/us-appeals-court-rejects-bid-block-land-swap-rios-arizona-copper-mine-2024-03-01/
MOMFUDSKI
(5,730 posts)Money is EVERYTHING, huh?
rpannier
(24,345 posts)Argue it as treaties and on religious grounds
They already have Grosuch's vote, and probably the 3 Democratic appointees
They might be able to find that 5th vote
angrychair
(8,748 posts)Even 500 years later
Igel
(35,382 posts)And lose about the same amount.
JoseBalow
(2,533 posts)The Apache don't own or control the land, but it is important to them and they don't want to see it destroyed.
In America, money always takes precedence over land and culture
angrychair
(8,748 posts)Where do you think think the federal government got that land? No one gave it to them.
JoseBalow
(2,533 posts)Where they got it from is a different and legit issue; All federal land used to belong to indigenous peoples, once.
angrychair
(8,748 posts)They are giving away land to billionaires that they stole from Native Americans.
No different than what has happened for hundreds of years to both Native Americans and Black people.
Mosby
(16,390 posts)angrychair
(8,748 posts)It is stolen. Soaked in the blood of people that had been here for thousands of years before the first white man set foot on it.
Mosby
(16,390 posts)Saying the US was stolen is an incredibly simplistic view of history, though I know it's quite popular these days.
I guess the murdering, raping, kidnapping and forced death marching of hundreds of thousands of Native Americans was all just a fantasy I created in my head. Silly me, I guess the white colonizers were just here to borrow a cup of maize.
Mosby
(16,390 posts)The way they were treated is a separate issue.
Celerity
(43,632 posts)Just like Columbus did....................
Deuxcents
(16,378 posts)Push em back from their ancestral roots and they can live somewhere else..we want the resources theyre sitting on. Thats how we do it and it aint right. Not then and not now.
hunter
(38,338 posts)We'll use this copper to make more unnecessary consumer crap.
The notion that we have to destroy the natural environment in order to save it is obscene.
AKwannabe
(5,685 posts)Just ask MT. Superfund cleanup on aisle Arizona!
mahina
(17,721 posts)Auwē, this is a terrible crime!