A Call to Arms at the Supreme Court by Linda Greenhouse
Conservative judges worry that the Second Amendment has become a second-class right.
'A specter is haunting the Supreme Court disrespect for the Second Amendment. Perhaps you havent realized that the Supreme Courts disinclination to expand on its landmark 2008 decision creating an individual right to gun ownership means that the justices are treating the Second Amendment as a second-class right. A watered-down right. A disfavored right.
If you are unaware of these outlandish claims, then you havent tuned into the rising chorus of judicial voices demanding more from the Supreme Court than gun fanciers already won in that intensely disputed 5-to-4 decision a decade ago, District of Columbia v. Heller.
Why is this happening, and why now? To understand why the second-class right meme is suddenly penetrating the judicial conversation, we have to begin with Justice Clarence Thomas. He is not the first member of the current Supreme Court to use the phrase; Justice Samuel Alito Jr. used it in his 2010 opinion that extended the analysis of the Heller decision, which had applied only to Washington, D.C., as a federal enclave, to the states. The court was being asked, Justice Alito wrote in McDonald v. City of Chicago, to treat the right recognized in Heller as a second-class right, which he said the court would not do.
But it is Justice Thomas who has taken up the phrase as a weapon, using it in a series of opinions over the past four years to accuse his colleagues of failing in their duty to keep pushing back against limitations on gun ownership and use. The opinions were all dissents from the courts decisions not to hear particular gun-rights appeals.'>>>
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/03/opinion/guns-second-amendment-supreme-court.html?
marble falls
(57,537 posts)of people. And those who support it most probably couldn't recognize it as it is written without the title 'Second Amendment" written over it.
Paladin
(28,287 posts)lagomorph777
(30,613 posts)Putin must have a lot of money to invest in making sure that Americans are too busy shooting each other to notice that he's taking over the world.