Ukraine's Counteroffensive Is More Successful Than You Think
The focus on the stalled land war obscures major successes in Crimea and the Black Sea.
A satellite image shows smoke billowing from the headquarters of the Russian Black Sea Fleet after a Ukrainian missile strike in Sevastopol, Crimea, on Sept. 22. PLANET LABS VIA REUTERS
(snip)
While some of this criticism may be justified, the almost singular Western focus on territorial breakthroughs has distracted from the fact that Ukraine is fighting a medium- to long-term war on multiple fronts against a significantly larger and heavily entrenched foe. Whats more, the lack of a major Ukrainian land advance obscures the very real battlefield successes Ukraine has had in other theaters of the conflictmost notably in Russian-occupied Crimea and the Black Sea.
A crucial part of Kyivs long-term plan for the war is to push Russia out of the Crimean Peninsula and the rest of the Russian-occupied parts of Ukraines coastline. Since the start of the full-scale invasion, Russias Black Sea Fleet, headquartered at the Crimean port of Sevastopol, has been a critical component of Moscows war effort. Russian warships operating out of Sevastopol have enforced a blockade of Ukraines coastline and launched cruise missiles to rain hell onto Ukrainian cities and infrastructure.
But over the last several months, Ukraine has achieved a series of startling victories in and around Crimea, including missile strikes against the Kerch Strait bridge and multiple daring attacks on the Black Sea Fleet itselfwith major impacts on the Russians ability to operate on the peninsula and in the western Black Sea.
In September, the Ukrainians carried out a series of missile strikes against Russian naval assets in Sevastopol, including a landing ship, a submarine, and the headquarters of the Black Sea Fleet itselfreportedly while several high-ranking commanders were inside. Some of these strikes were carried out using Storm Shadow cruise missiles recently supplied by Britain and France. The Ukrainians have also ratcheted up their strikes against Russian logistics, repair, and infrastructure hubs on the peninsula with the intent of degrading Russias ability to support its fleet. Earlier this month, Kyiv claimed responsibility for two further attacks on the Russian fleet, using a new type of sea drone to strike the Russian cruise missile carrier Buyan and carrying out a sabotage attack on the Pavel Derzhavin, a Russian patrol ship. These strikes came after the Ukrainians had methodically attrited Russian anti-missile defense structures in Crimea over the previous weeks.
(snip)
https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/10/20/ukraine-crimea-black-sea-counteroffensive-russia-fleet-navy-drones-war/
PortTack
(32,840 posts)Bernardo de La Paz
(49,098 posts)Russia's collapse in Ukraine and Crimea will likely come slowly and then suddenly.
People will say "How did that happen so suddenly?"
If it happens, it will be because of the loss of many Ukrainian lives, the tremendous bravery of a few, and the solid quiet bravery of many, over months of war and suffering. Months of strenuous effort to rid themselves (again) of oppressors with no moral boundaries. Soviets, then Nazis, then Russians.
Ukraine has been hollowing out Russian military steadily. Russia, which has generations of not only making but designing whole series of aircraft, has been unable to establish air superiority over Ukraine. Russian Generals and top brass dying near the fronts. In the last couple of weeks Russia has been making a bit of a counter-counter-offensive at Adviikia (sp?) and another place, with no success and large losses. But I've only read a few reports.