Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NRaleighLiberal

(60,041 posts)
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 05:07 PM Jun 2012

OK - apples and oranges, I know. Toyota Prius or Subaru Forrester? or something else?

Last car we bought was a 2005 Forrester - we love it. also have a 2002 Toyota Tacoma - still love it. We tend to keep our cars until they die - but we want to give our 2005 Forrester to our daughter and get something new.

we just test drove the Prius - Fun! - and the Forrester - kinda boring, seemed a bit cheaply made on the inside.

We've read that the current Civic hybrid did not rate well.

So what else should I consider, if not one of these two?

21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
OK - apples and oranges, I know. Toyota Prius or Subaru Forrester? or something else? (Original Post) NRaleighLiberal Jun 2012 OP
Prius (or Priapus)... NYC_SKP Jun 2012 #1
....And you can VIOLATE EVERY TRAFFIC LAW in the state where Skippy lives cliffordu Jun 2012 #14
Luis misses you. NYC_SKP Jun 2012 #16
I'm really glad YOU missed him. cliffordu Jun 2012 #18
Prius. emilyg Jun 2012 #2
How about a new Impreza? (or any Subie) we can do it Jun 2012 #3
Where do you live? How many miles a yr do you drive? nt Honeycombe8 Jun 2012 #4
Raleigh - about 10K per year. NRaleighLiberal Jun 2012 #5
So you don't absolutely need the mileage of the Prius. That makes you choice easier.... Honeycombe8 Jun 2012 #7
Sticker price for both was about equal....with me out of work, the $$$ matters - NRaleighLiberal Jun 2012 #9
Intellichoice says 5 yr ownership cost of 2012 Forester=$35,626, for 2012 5drHB Prius=$35,869. Honeycombe8 Jun 2012 #10
I saw the new large Prius on the road recently. It's a beauty. But the Forester... Honeycombe8 Jun 2012 #6
If you've got a space that wide between models I think maybe you need to narrow down your needs. LeftyMom Jun 2012 #8
For small... TreasonousBastard Jun 2012 #11
thanks for the ideas. We had a Passat - loved it - but big maintenance bucks. NRaleighLiberal Jun 2012 #12
Bummer about that Passat, so I can see why... TreasonousBastard Jun 2012 #13
I second the Focus. They're great cars. Brickbat Jun 2012 #17
Subaru will be on the road for decades longer than the Prius. sinkingfeeling Jun 2012 #15
as a Subaru owner keep the Forester tabbycat31 Jun 2012 #19
How about an American brand? I'm considering one of these for my next car: Initech Jun 2012 #20
Subaru doesn't make vehicles. They make bumper cars. HopeHoops Jun 2012 #21
 

NYC_SKP

(68,644 posts)
1. Prius (or Priapus)...
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 05:27 PM
Jun 2012

I have one with 110K miles on it and no issues every. I have fit such things as a 10 foot kayak and 10 foot lengths of lumber in it WITH THE HATCH DOWN and drive it all around town and into other states with nary a care.

I would go for the Plug-In Prius, or at least look into it.

GF has a Civic Hybrid, it's a nicer ride but less versatile because it's a sedan.

cliffordu

(30,994 posts)
14. ....And you can VIOLATE EVERY TRAFFIC LAW in the state where Skippy lives
Thu Jun 14, 2012, 10:35 AM
Jun 2012

with one of these bad boys.


Christ almighty, I thought we were auditioning for the Grand Theft Auto version of "Top Gun"

70 in a 35, 85 in a 60.......People in line at the taco truck where we ate lunch scattered like cats as we slid sideways into the gravel parking lot and he exclaimed

"See???!! I TOLD you we'd be the first in line!"

cliffordu

(30,994 posts)
18. I'm really glad YOU missed him.
Thu Jun 14, 2012, 12:06 PM
Jun 2012

GREAT carnitas -

Good to see you still working at the driving school, too.

Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
7. So you don't absolutely need the mileage of the Prius. That makes you choice easier....
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 10:44 PM
Jun 2012

or harder, depending on how you look at it.

You can get the Forester w/o it hitting you too hard in the wallet for the extra $ you'll pay for gas. Still, that'll add up over the years. You can calculate that out.

NRaleighLiberal

(60,041 posts)
9. Sticker price for both was about equal....with me out of work, the $$$ matters -
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 10:54 PM
Jun 2012

and we like the elevated "greenness" of the Prius in using less gas.

we really didn't enjoy driving the Forester that much - considering it was 7 years newer than the one we own, we didn't think it advanced at all. The Prius was much more fun to drive (probably because it was novel).

We won't go wrong with either...and are in no rush to buy immediately.

thanks!

Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
10. Intellichoice says 5 yr ownership cost of 2012 Forester=$35,626, for 2012 5drHB Prius=$35,869.
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 11:18 PM
Jun 2012

www.intellichoice.com

Even so, it rates the VALUE of the Prius as excellent, but the VALUE of the Forester as above avg. You pay several thousand more in, gas for the Forester, but more for repairs & maintenance. The Prius costs a couple thousand more up front, but the cost of ownership holds up better over time than the Forester.

Do you need the extra space the Forester has? Do you need the AWD? If not, there's no pressing reason to get the Forester. Unless you just love it, like I do. The Forester has the best driver position of any car on the road, IMO.

Do you need a loaner car when you get your car serviced? You won't get that with the Prius (or at least we don't get that here in Dallas).

Subarus are costly to repair.

As for me, I'm going to check out that larger Prius. I have an add'l problem, which is a tiny garage.

I ended up buying a Honda Fit. I get good gas mileage, a car that holds a ton of stuff, a zippy little urban commuter, a cute car, and it was inexpensive with a very high resale value. I had to buy a new car in a hurry, so I just got a Fit to keep for a couple of years. I only drive $6k-$8k a year, so I don't need a hybrid, altho I'd like one.

Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
6. I saw the new large Prius on the road recently. It's a beauty. But the Forester...
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 10:39 PM
Jun 2012

Iowned a Subie Forester for 14 years. Best, most reliable, most useful, most comfortable (for the driver) vehicle I ever owned.



I test drove the new Forester....I didn't like it as much as the old Forester. But still an awesome car that is unmatched for what it can be used for. The interior is not as nice as other cars. But you can't beat the AWD, the looks (but not as cool looking as old Foresters), the utility (large cargo with seats that fold down flat easily). I just love Foresters.

I test drove a couple of Prii. Meh. Nice. But sort of bland. Still, it has a cargo area. I think the seats folded down flat for cargo, but you had to pull seats forward or something? Maybe not.

I didn't buy either, though, because in both, you had to get leather seats to get the top model, and with the Forester you also had to get a moonroof. I won't buy leather seats. And I do NOT want a moonroof.

Bad thing about Subie in my area (Dallas) is there arent many dealerships here. The Toyota dealership closest to me was in an inconvenient location, plus I didn't like the people there.

The thing about a Prius is....if you drive a lot of miles, you'll save money buy getting the Prius. The Forester's gas mileage isn't very good. It's not bad, but it's not good. (check out Consumerreports.org for actual mileage as tested)

Subie: Better a/c than Prius. Prius has all that slanted glass, so it's harder to keep it cool and the sun off of you (I live in a hot area).

My heart says Subie. I just love 'em. But my practical brain says a Prius is the better deal over the long haul, if you don't need a Subie's AWD, extra cargo, utilitarian use, and such.

But that new large Prius was a beauty. I don't know how much they cost, but I would consider buying one of those, if not tooooo costly. It'd be more useful than the smaller Prius.


Subie: You get a loaner car when you get the car serviced. Toyota: No loaner car.

LeftyMom

(49,212 posts)
8. If you've got a space that wide between models I think maybe you need to narrow down your needs.
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 10:52 PM
Jun 2012

You said above you'll put 10K a year on it and that you intend to keep the car for it's useful lifespan, so it sounds like reliability and long term cost of ownership are major factors. What's the terrain? Do you need another vehicle with AWD? What are your needs for space for cargo, passengers, etc? Is it mostly for commuting or family trips? Do you need a vehicle of that size or with access to the Subie and the truck would you be better off with a smaller, more efficient third vehicle? It sounds like maybe you prefer two box models (ie wagons and hatchbacks) to three box models (sedans with separate trunks,) if that's the case it narrows your options somewhat, but they're popular these days so you'll have plenty of choices.

Once you've thought through those questions you should have a category of vehicles you're looking at, like economy hatchbacks or AWD wagons or something, and then you can narrow down models by their differences from there. Looking at two wildly disparate vehicles in totally different classes generally suggests (with some exceptions) that a buyer needs to spend more time thinking less about individual models and more about their own use and needs, which they can match up to models later on in the process.

TreasonousBastard

(43,049 posts)
11. For small...
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 11:33 PM
Jun 2012

move back to the States and look at the Buick Verano or the new Ford Focus. They beat most things from Asia lately and the gas money you would save with the Prius is negligable. For really, really small, Sonics and Fiestas are definitely worth a look

Bigger stuff? Chevy Equinox with the four or the latest Ford Escape.

Volkswagen Passat? Hyundai Sonata? Japan is kinda falling behind the pack in style, reliability, and performance in everyday cars.

NRaleighLiberal

(60,041 posts)
12. thanks for the ideas. We had a Passat - loved it - but big maintenance bucks.
Wed Jun 13, 2012, 11:37 PM
Jun 2012

Car was just too fussy - turbo blew, and once the rods blew - very costly.

Just beginning my research - these are good ideas.

Initech

(100,152 posts)
20. How about an American brand? I'm considering one of these for my next car:
Thu Jun 14, 2012, 02:01 PM
Jun 2012

Fusion:



Chrysler 300:



Impala:

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»OK - apples and oranges, ...