Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

intrepidity

(7,331 posts)
Fri Jul 28, 2023, 02:37 PM Jul 2023

Electronic contact cleaner vs brake parts cleaner spray: difference?

Is it that the electronic spray is "cleaner" or more refined (ie, no contaminants) while the brake parts cleaner is good for parts without electrical plugs etc?

Is it bad to use the brake cleaner in the engine compartment to degrease?

29 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Electronic contact cleaner vs brake parts cleaner spray: difference? (Original Post) intrepidity Jul 2023 OP
I would not use it to degrease an entire engine compartment MichMan Jul 2023 #1
It was just a matter of what was on hand at the moment intrepidity Jul 2023 #10
Probably more a difference in moisture level and evaporation rates Hugh_Lebowski Jul 2023 #2
Gotcha. intrepidity Jul 2023 #11
There are differences taxi Jul 2023 #3
Depending what state the OP lives in, they may not have the choice to buy chlorinated MichMan Jul 2023 #4
That is true. It's definitely a good idea to test the product first. taxi Jul 2023 #5
Ah, thanks for those details intrepidity Jul 2023 #12
Here's hoping your project goes well. taxi Jul 2023 #17
Sound advice intrepidity Jul 2023 #18
Glad to help when possible. taxi Jul 2023 #19
Yeah... intrepidity Jul 2023 #20
Typically a green wire is a ground, but NOT every time. taxi Jul 2023 #21
Chlorinated brake cleaner kills. Hermit-The-Prog Sep 2023 #26
At least not anything hotter than 700 degrees. taxi Sep 2023 #27
500F / 260C is enough to produce phosgene gas. Hermit-The-Prog Sep 2023 #28
As I mentioned about rarified instances, taxi Sep 2023 #29
I get a longer buzz from the brake cleaner, but less of an "edge" from the contact cleaner Effete Snob Jul 2023 #6
See, now you bring up yet another application to consider intrepidity Jul 2023 #13
Regulation lacquer thinner (not the synthetic) is the best high if you're huffin. Hotler Sep 2023 #24
What I can't figure out is why anyone would want to clean their engine compartment? Chainfire Jul 2023 #7
Don't have a mower or deck, so can't speak to that. intrepidity Jul 2023 #14
Look at the MSDS sheets for each product MichMan Jul 2023 #8
Yeah, but first I must find them intrepidity Jul 2023 #15
This guy has some good tips about cleaning an engine compartment... mitch96 Jul 2023 #9
Chris Fix is one of my go-tos intrepidity Jul 2023 #16
here are some connector pix taxi Aug 2023 #22
Can't see em here neither... intrepidity Aug 2023 #23
I reccomend PJ1, find it at most motorcycle dealers and part stores. Hotler Sep 2023 #25

MichMan

(11,958 posts)
1. I would not use it to degrease an entire engine compartment
Fri Jul 28, 2023, 02:54 PM
Jul 2023

Pretty agressive formula and you don't need to breathe it. It can be pretty nasty stuff. Might damage any painted components.

I would only use it to degrease or clean smaller individual components. There are other degreasers for an entire engine compartment that would be a lot better to use .

 

Hugh_Lebowski

(33,643 posts)
2. Probably more a difference in moisture level and evaporation rates
Fri Jul 28, 2023, 02:57 PM
Jul 2023

Contact cleaner is likely to be a lighter and much more fast-evaporating than break cleaner.

I don't think there'd be a problem using break cleaner in engine compartment though, no. Except maybe not best for cleaning the fuse box.

Edit: Also agree with MichMan ... for spot cleaning most places probably fine, for whole compartment, go w/something designed for the purpose.

taxi

(1,896 posts)
3. There are differences
Fri Jul 28, 2023, 02:58 PM
Jul 2023

Be careful before using non-clorinated brake cleaner over coated areas - it melts the epoxy on your garage floor where regular brake cleaner doesn't. On the other hand, regular brake cleaner will melt softer plastics like those in car stereos, but is okay on the more rugged plastics in the engine compartment.

In cleaning an engine compartment brake cleaner is the first thing I have always used. Anything left that hasn't come off can be scrapped off or picked out. Stay away from the non-clorinated.

taxi

(1,896 posts)
5. That is true. It's definitely a good idea to test the product first.
Fri Jul 28, 2023, 03:48 PM
Jul 2023

It's been a handful of years since it melted the floor in my ex's garage - it made one hell of a mess. I had replaced the front brakes on her car and what washed off fused into the epoxy. There was nothing I could do to clean it up prior to letting the car down and it stayed soft long enough to leave an imprint of the tire tread for a few feet. For the other side I put down a couple layers of cardboard first. It may be possible that the formula has been improved. The cleaner I currently have is non-chlorinated and was used to clean off the entire front of a motor that I changed out the AC compressor on. No problems.

intrepidity

(7,331 posts)
12. Ah, thanks for those details
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 03:36 PM
Jul 2023

Turns out the stuff I have *is* non-chlorinated (CA here). But, I should be fine, since I don't have a garage.

Very good to know about the epoxy anyway.

taxi

(1,896 posts)
17. Here's hoping your project goes well.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:05 PM
Jul 2023

I find that when looking at a motor for leaks or stains, peering just over the fenders from as low of an angle as possible helps. Often those trying to sell or buy a vehicle will not look from as far forward (near the headlight) or as far back (by the hinge) as possible, they stand by the wheel well and miss the hidden areas. Have some zip ties and/or electrical tape on hand for any wires that may be hanging or out of place. Wires, hoses, and tubing are easily cleaned by spraying some WD40-type product on a rag, wrapping it around, and pulling for the length of it. For cleaning up your hands keep a bucket of soapy water handy. Good luck.

intrepidity

(7,331 posts)
18. Sound advice
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:12 PM
Jul 2023

Removed my alternator and just got another, but wanted to clean up around there before installing it.

Also, I spotted a dangling (cut) green wire in that area that I'm trying to identify, so removing gunk. Still have not ID'd it yet.

Thanks

taxi

(1,896 posts)
19. Glad to help when possible.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 04:33 PM
Jul 2023

On many metric motorcycles a stator is used instead of an alternator, with the voltage regulator separate. Sometimes when people have change out their batteries they connect the negative first, and then the positive. What happens is they end up blowing out a diode, which in turn can burn out the stator. That is why the instructions always say to disconnect the negative first; when reconnecting it's the positive first. Anyway, I ramble...

intrepidity

(7,331 posts)
20. Yeah...
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 07:48 PM
Jul 2023

My diodes were blown, and I did have a bad habit of thinking that the + connected alone was safer than the ground connected alone.... *totally* the opposite of the correct way, sigh...

I am having a helluva time identifying this broken wire hanging below where the alternator goes! I have the full FSM for my vehicle (2001 4runner) and have now spent two days looking at nearly every page (over 2000!) trying to id which sensor might be missing it's connection. I want to figure this out before reinstalling the new alt. Arrgh.

taxi

(1,896 posts)
21. Typically a green wire is a ground, but NOT every time.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 08:58 PM
Jul 2023

I will write up how to know what it is and message you.

taxi

(1,896 posts)
27. At least not anything hotter than 700 degrees.
Sat Sep 16, 2023, 05:58 AM
Sep 2023

Fortunately finding an area of that high of a temperature on a typical car is difficult, especially if the engine has been turned off and is being worked on. But, as I sometimes say about some media outlets, one person out of hundreds of millions can do some outrageous act and it gets portrayed as the norm.
I do appreciate the info you gave however. I was unaware of the perils and conditions under which they existed until now. As soon as I saw tetro, carbon tet came to mind, as well as when seeing per did perchlorate.
In addition, its effects on memory help to explain why as a Iong time mechanic I'm so easily confused.
A good find none the less.

Hermit-The-Prog

(33,389 posts)
28. 500F / 260C is enough to produce phosgene gas.
Sat Sep 16, 2023, 06:27 AM
Sep 2023
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brake_cleaner
https://www.popsci.com/diy/article/2009-12/dont-get-careless/
https://outsidegroove.com/2021/01/chlorinated-brake-cleaner-welder-beware/

https://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/buying-maintenance/a33229282/brakleen-safety-brake-cleaner-august-2020/
"likely to be carcinogenic in humans by all routes of exposure.”

https://www.epa.gov/assessing-and-managing-chemicals-under-tsca/fact-sheet-trichloroethylene-tce
These proposed regulatory actions follow a June 2014 TSCA Work Plan Chemical Risk Assessment for TCE that identified serious risks to workers associated with this TCE use and concluded that the chemical can cause a range of adverse health effects, including cancer, developmental and neurotoxicological effects, and toxicity to the liver.

taxi

(1,896 posts)
29. As I mentioned about rarified instances,
Sat Sep 16, 2023, 06:45 AM
Sep 2023

it always puzzled me how ski resorts can make snow when it's close to 40 degrees. But you have a point.

 

Effete Snob

(8,387 posts)
6. I get a longer buzz from the brake cleaner, but less of an "edge" from the contact cleaner
Fri Jul 28, 2023, 03:56 PM
Jul 2023

Overall, the contact cleaner is better if I have only a few hours before I have to report to my job as a commercial airline pilot, but want to get my freak on for a while first.

But if I have a hotel room for the weekend, some crank, and a couple of "friends" (wink, wink), then the brake cleaner is the bomb.

Chainfire

(17,587 posts)
7. What I can't figure out is why anyone would want to clean their engine compartment?
Fri Jul 28, 2023, 04:23 PM
Jul 2023

Next thing you will tell me that people wash mower decks...

intrepidity

(7,331 posts)
14. Don't have a mower or deck, so can't speak to that.
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 03:40 PM
Jul 2023

Normally, I let sleeping dogs lie, but I'm trying to visually inspect certain parts/areas that are covered in gunk, so...

intrepidity

(7,331 posts)
15. Yeah, but first I must find them
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 03:45 PM
Jul 2023

and worse, then I must interpret and understand them, which would no doubt lead to me posting on DU. So, I cut out the middleman.

But thanks for the most logical answer.

intrepidity

(7,331 posts)
16. Chris Fix is one of my go-tos
Sat Jul 29, 2023, 03:47 PM
Jul 2023

I didn't want to do a thorough cleaning ("thorough" is his middle name), just needed to spot clean some areas using what I had on hand.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»DIY & Home Improvement»Electronic contact cleane...