Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Eugene

(61,974 posts)
Tue Jan 29, 2019, 01:49 AM Jan 2019

US Nobelist was told of gene-edited babies

Source: Associated Press

AP Exclusive: US Nobelist was told of gene-edited babies

By CANDICE CHOI and MARILYNN MARCHIONE
January 28, 2019

Long before the claim of the world’s first gene-edited babies became public, Chinese researcher He Jiankui shared the news with a U.S. Nobel laureate who objected to the experiment yet remained an adviser to He’s biotech company.

The revelation that another prominent scientist knew of the work, which was widely condemned when it was revealed, comes as scientists debate whether and how to alert troubling research, and the need for clearer guidelines.

Emails obtained by The Associated Press under a public records request show that Nobel Prize winner Craig Mello of the University of Massachusetts learned about the pregnancy last April from He in a message titled “Success!”

“I’m glad for you, but I’d rather not be kept in the loop on this,” Mello replied. “You are risking the health of the child you are editing ... I just don’t see why you are doing this. I wish your patient the best of luck for a healthy pregnancy.”

Mello stayed on as a scientific adviser for He’s Direct Genomics company for eight more months, until December, just after news of the births became public and drew international scorn. The Chinese scientist’s gene-editing work was not a company experiment. He tried to alter the genes of twin girls to help them resist possible future infection with HIV, the AIDS virus.

-snip-

Read more: https://apnews.com/3f3bdc73e7c84fe685f2813510329d62

2 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
US Nobelist was told of gene-edited babies (Original Post) Eugene Jan 2019 OP
In the blurb, 3 of the 4 sentences quoted from that email seem appropriate, but the 1st one? Yech! RockRaven Jan 2019 #1
If he had ethical concerns he should have reported him Pachamama Jan 2019 #2

RockRaven

(15,093 posts)
1. In the blurb, 3 of the 4 sentences quoted from that email seem appropriate, but the 1st one? Yech!
Tue Jan 29, 2019, 02:12 AM
Jan 2019

"I'm glad for you, but I'd rather not be kept in the loop on this" is going to get more attention than his admonishment. And probably should. Because an appropriate response would have been just the admonishment (and then some), not the warm fuzzy feelings and a request for plausible deniability.

From what I've seen, heard, and read from other sources, this undertaking is an bioethical horror show. And the fact that Mello stayed on for eight more months, and only left as an advisor after the widespread and justified (as far as I can tell from what's publicly available) uproar is NOT exactly awe inspiring. If he had ethical concerns, he should have cut ties sooner. If he didn't have ethical concerns, he's a f-ing moral monster (again, this judgement is based on what's been made public so far).

Pachamama

(16,887 posts)
2. If he had ethical concerns he should have reported him
Tue Jan 29, 2019, 03:49 AM
Jan 2019

...immediately and resigned from his company and spoken out vigorously.

He didn’t care - in fact, it feels like he was excited about the pregnancy and he said nothing beyond a bare attempt for plausible deniability.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»US Nobelist was told of g...