2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumBeyond Voting for & Supporting...What a Difference a Kaine Might Make
I will vote for Hillary Clinton in November. I have supported Hillary Clinton for President since before she announced she was running and I will support her through November. She really must win.
I have a horrible dread inside me this morning that I've never felt before now for political reasons.
I am motivated by Hillary to help her win and against Trump to help her win. As the idea of VP Kaine leaks as a likelihood, my motivation has tilted from the former motivation toward the latter, my antipathy for all things Trump stands for.
I find myself very somber this morning from a combination of Trump's frightening vision for our country and a fear of what Kaine's choice by Sec. Clinton portends for the outcome of her alternative candidacy.
We need everyone possible to vote for Sec. Clinton, obviously. But less obviously, we need so many people personally motivated to give of themselves in time, physical effort and money to make this happen. This effort is what produces enough votes to win. I know the kinds of people who have sat beside me phone banking registering voters for hours, walked with me during door-to-door canvassing, and helped me coordinate and drive hundreds/thousands of voters to poll locations to vote.
For the life of me, I do not see how Sen. Kaine and his pro-TPP & pro-bank deregulation stances, along with his non-charismatic personality that no one discounts, adds motivation to those usually doing the work, let alone to people who will do nothing but vote (or not) this election cycle. I think a vp pick of Warren or another progressive would motivate many more new volunteers and so much more strongly inspire the regulars who are needed.
What difference this will make is yet to be seen...but I have a sense of dread that isn't going away this morning.
NBachers
(17,192 posts)An "I'll show up and vote" choice, instead of an "I'm inspired and I'll run with it" choice.
fun n serious
(4,451 posts)I am already excited and inspired by Hillary.
Bluenorthwest
(45,319 posts)change of hearts and minds. He signed anti gay legislation he had promised to veto. He is definitive of the past wrongs of this Party.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)I've never forced myself to vote for a presidential candidate in spite of their VP choice. And ... I've never not voted for a presidential candidate because of their VP choice.
farmboy
(252 posts)making the extra effort to help Hillary win. That would be the difference.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)Are you referring to the ultra-liberal wing of our party?
farmboy
(252 posts)Some that I speak with at work. Some that I correspond with as friends, through personal email, twitter, and other means. Family members who I've spoken with in the last week. My own 74 yr old mother and 39 year old sister, both who saw reports yesterday of Kaine being the likely pick and were dumbfounded why she wasn't picking Elizabeth Warren after seeing them together earlier this year. That is just a start. There are others that I don't know because I know I am not an isolated individual. These are all people who will vote for Hillary but who put in differing amounts of time and effort in GOTV efforts depending on motivation and inspiration.
Kaine is dead weight as a motivating factor, especially since there were easily more progressive choices than he to pair with Hillary's own less than abundantly left-leaning past.
Expecting Rain
(811 posts)And we are mainstream Democrats who always vote and always vote Democratic.
I started volunteering at the age of 10, when I worked on the RFK campaign in California. Then again for McGovern in '72 (at 14).
I've volunteered in most presidential races since. Phone banked for Obama and helped fundraise both times.
I like HRC. But this choice of Kaine is dispiriting in the extreme.
Warren would have fired enthusiasm. Kaine is like a wet-blanket.
This pick will make getting out the vote a chore, for an election we must not lose.
So color me: Very very disappointed.
Bill
farmboy
(252 posts)Let's do what we can, whatever it may be, for the best possible outcome given the cards we are dealt.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)... people who are less motivated, like the ones you've described. I've never really understood people who felt that they could only support a candidate if they "fell-in-love" with that candidate. I tend to look at things more logically, rather than being motivated strictly by emotions.
That's not the role of a VP selection.
She doesn't need anyone or anything to "balance" her campaign. She's always campaigned from the center. A little left here, a little right there, but on the whole, she's squarely in the center.
Elections are won from the center. That's why Hillary won the primary and that's why she'll win the General Election. The VP selection isn't a consolation prize for those who didn't support her. If it was, she'd have picked Bernie. Instead, she picks someone that she feels is qualified, and that she gets along with and can work with.
farmboy
(252 posts)I don't need to fall-in-love with a candidate. I need to see that he/she is heading in a governing direction that I can accept. I have supported Hillary and will continue to do so. I will vote for her. I say that over and over as to not be misunderstood. But this vp choice is a MAJOR decision, a factor that lets me glimpse her thinking, and a Kaine choice would leave me incredibly discouraged.
You say Hillary has always campaigned from the center. I agree. But "always", as in the past, may not be what is need for NOW or in the future. She did win the primary, closely. I supported her. Bernie Sanders would not have been a vp consolation prize for me, I can tell you. But other qualified progressives as vp would have added what I think is needed currently to bring together the largest segments of our citizenry that are apt to vote Democratic this year. THIS YEAR. Times do change, and I think the primary season demonstrated that.
The past sometimes bites you in the ass if you live in it too long. I hope that is not what happens to us Democrats this year, because it would be a most poisonous bite!
fun n serious
(4,451 posts)Sen. Tim Kaine is a foot soldier in the Obama Coalition, regardless of his race. Was an early Obama endorser in 2008 and was his DNC chair.
Expecting Rain
(811 posts)Nor do I need to "fall in love with a candidate" as a previous poster insultingly suggests.
A hard political calculus shows HRC pretty much owns the center, a good place to be in electoral politics. But the Democratic party is a big tent. HRC beat Bernie Sanders, but the margin of victory over a virtually unknown Senator from a small state who only sort-of-just joined the party should not make any of those who supported her feel over-confident, especially when comparing the youth vote.
I want, beyond any other consideration, to win in November. To win the White House. To win the Senate. And to get close in the House.
My hard-headed analysis is that a Clinton-Warren ticket would be far more conducive to meeting those ends than a Clinton-Kaine ticket. I think picking him will be a very bad choice, in a year when we can afford self-inflicted errors.