Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

NanceGreggs

(27,821 posts)
Sat Jul 1, 2023, 04:53 AM Jul 2023

It hurts me to say this ... [View all]

... but I will say it nonetheless.

I moved to Canada in 1974, when my then-husband was offered a lucrative, career-advancing job. When we split-up three years later, I chose to stay here. Neither decision had anything to do with politics - in fact, I was rather apolitical at the time.

But I always took pride in the fact that I was an American. Over the years, I amassed a sizeable collection of American flag pins and brooches, which I always wore. I owned an over-sized American flag, which I displayed on my front porch on every US holiday. My place became known as 'the house with the flag' among neighbours and fast-food delivery people alike.

I always made it known that I was a US citizen, because I took pride in the place I came from and its people. I took pride in the fact that my country - for all its faults and mis-steps - was always striving to form "a more perfect union".

I was proud when my countrymen united after the attacks of 9/11. I was proud when my nation elected its first black president. I was proud when same-sex marriage became the law of the land.

But now my pride has turned to shame - shame that so many of my fellow citizens have chosen bigotry over inclusiveness, hatred over love of country, violence over the peaceful resolution of our differences.

I am ashamed of self-proclaimed "Christians" who have abandoned the teachings of Christ, of politicians who have abandoned their oaths of office, and of citizens who have abandoned every principle my country was founded upon.

Above all else, I am ashamed of my own gratitude that I live in a country that isn't the United States, but in a country where my lesbian daughter is safe, a country where school children are not gunned-down by assault-weapon-wielding murderers, a place where bigotry is not welcomed nor accepted, no less openly encouraged.

My giant American flag is safely packed away, along with my collection of "I'm a proud American" jewelry.

I hope for the day when I will not be ashamed to display them as proudly as I once did.


75 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
It hurts me to say this ... [View all] NanceGreggs Jul 2023 OP
I share your shame, and feel your pain. ariadne0614 Jul 2023 #1
I love Toronto. NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #3
Toronto is wonderful! ariadne0614 Jul 2023 #20
My pride has always been mixed with shame EYESORE 9001 Jul 2023 #2
+1 2naSalit Jul 2023 #9
Excellent post. llmart Jul 2023 #42
I feel the same way, Nance Martin Eden Jul 2023 #4
How indeed. NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #6
I am starting to believe we are going to have another civil war. MySideOfTown Jul 2023 #5
Yeah, well ... NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #7
I never thought it would come to this. MySideOfTown Jul 2023 #11
I'm not a Canadian. NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #15
You can't vote, but I can, so you can't help us. MySideOfTown Jul 2023 #18
Any American citizen can vote in the USA, no matter where they live DFW Jul 2023 #21
Apparently you don't know ... NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #23
Canadian at heart, American not so much MySideOfTown Jul 2023 #26
Yeah, you are. NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #28
That's pretty insulting. Eko Jul 2023 #57
Kiddie pool. rubbersole Jul 2023 #59
You're a prepper, he's a prepper, she's a prepper... johnp3907 Jul 2023 #43
not gonna 4th of july this year dembotoz Jul 2023 #8
Same here... 2naSalit Jul 2023 #10
I am one of these old school dudes that put their flag out on the appropriate holidays. Prairie_Seagull Jul 2023 #70
My feelings about our country changed with Viet Nam. Fortunately, Viet Nam was a "one off." 3Hotdogs Jul 2023 #12
unfortunately the trump stain on the country is permanent. Indelible. mnmoderatedem Jul 2023 #13
Nothing is permanent. Nt 1WorldHope Jul 2023 #64
We are a failed nation because it's The Wizard Jul 2023 #14
I hear you Nance Skittles Jul 2023 #16
Since the Roman empire took control of Chrisitanity it's been a tool Model35mech Jul 2023 #17
My husband is a Canadian and when we married in 1973 we almost moved to Canada to Vinca Jul 2023 #19
Too damn cold. tavernier Jul 2023 #22
Just a correction here. NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #25
I was raised in Michigan. tavernier Jul 2023 #27
You still haven't explained ... NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #32
I'm a cold weather person - hate the heat. Last summer we baked in southern NH and Vinca Jul 2023 #31
I hear ya! NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #33
I'm not there yet DFW Jul 2023 #24
+1000 "Ignorance is our worst enemy" FakeNoose Jul 2023 #30
For anyone considering relocating to Toronto--get in line: DFW Jul 2023 #63
The hell of it is, MOST people in the US are DECENT people, and even though we are supposed ... 70sEraVet Jul 2023 #29
Agreed. NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #34
My friend played hockey in Oshawa years back, and loved my time in the Toronto area. sarcasmo Jul 2023 #35
Florida dems hope Canada doesn't build a wall, just in case DeSantis 2024... Timeflyer Jul 2023 #36
Kick dalton99a Jul 2023 #37
Happy Canada Day, eh? Swede Jul 2023 #38
I harbor no delusions. usonian Jul 2023 #39
Joe Biden is a "Class Act" and someone to be "Proud Of" Stuart G Jul 2023 #40
So sadly true and very well said, Nance Tom Rinaldo Jul 2023 #41
Thank you. ggma Jul 2023 #48
Well said JonAndKatePlusABird Jul 2023 #51
Your approach is wrong... brooklynite Jul 2023 #44
I'm sure there will be more moments you can take pride. LiberalFighter Jul 2023 #45
Canadian by birth Old Crank Jul 2023 #46
Well said, you've spoken for millions.. Permanut Jul 2023 #47
You can never let your guard down. Hope22 Jul 2023 #49
Just got back from British Columbia. Canadians were SO nice! And when asked where we were from, wiggs Jul 2023 #50
Bikinis and beaches and Hollywood. calimary Jul 2023 #53
They haven't abandoned the teachings of the demigod at all ExWhoDoesntCare Jul 2023 #52
Thanks for sharing that Nance. I am envious and also aware that Canada has a past as well. But Evolve Dammit Jul 2023 #54
My daughter mgardener Jul 2023 #55
I understand, Nance. I have a US flag I proudly carried in marches against Bush the Lesser... Hekate Jul 2023 #56
I would love to be able to move to Canada. ShazzieB Jul 2023 #58
If you're serious about moving here ... NanceGreggs Jul 2023 #61
Home is where the heart is and you're happy where you are Deuxcents Jul 2023 #65
We watched "Inherit the Wind" last night. SleeplessinSoCal Jul 2023 #60
Nance, I get you. But I live in a place in the US where I am surrounded by nature within Martin68 Jul 2023 #62
Things have changed here wendyb-NC Jul 2023 #66
I know exactly what you mean. Jedi Guy Jul 2023 #67
The extreme wings are getting way too much of a share of the conversation gulliver Jul 2023 #68
Bookmarking. Wonderful OP and thread with the exception of a Boomerproud Jul 2023 #69
Which brings to couple slightly rhetorical questions. The Grand Illuminist Jul 2023 #71
You are fully entitled to your shame re the U.S. Glad you're safe in Canada. (nt) Paladin Jul 2023 #72
Totally get it. And the reasoning behind it. calimary Oct 2023 #73
+1 MontanaMama Oct 2023 #74
Totally and enthusiastically agreed!!! calimary Oct 2023 #75
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»It hurts me to say this ....