General Discussion

Celerity

(43,903 posts)

65. Tit for tat, back & forth, w/ Israel doing the vast amount of the killing & land taking over the sweep of last century.

Reply to Mosby (Reply #58)

Tue Mar 19, 2024, 02:59 PM

Mar 19

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

78 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

'Zone of Interest' producer says he 'fundamentally disagrees' with Jonathan Glazer's Oscars speech on Israel-Hamas war [View all] Beastly Boy Mar 16 OP

So dehumanization only concerns him when it's applied to Jewish/Israeli people. Sky Jewels Mar 16 #1

How in the world would you reach this conclusion? Beastly Boy Mar 16 #2

It's sad you came to that ludicrous conclusion BannonsLiver Mar 16 #5

You just made that up, full cloth. Ace Rothstein Mar 16 #9

. sarisataka Mar 16 #10

Danny Cohen is Exactly Correct! Cha Mar 16 #26

A glorious pile of malarkey NoRethugFriends Mar 16 #29

Sadly, this seems to be the case for so many Israli's and rabid far rightwingers worldwide NYC2ATL Mar 16 #31

Oh yeah.. and what's the Butchers of HAMAS' Fucking "reputation"? Cha Mar 16 #35

Whenever you find yourself comparing a government of a Western nation to a terrorist group NYC2ATL Mar 16 #36

I'm not "comparing" anything .. The Distraction Cha Mar 16 #37

Post removed Post removed Mar 16 #38

Still Not working. Cha Mar 16 #39

I didn't lose. Cha Mar 17 #44

A lot of that going around nowadays ZonkerHarris Mar 18 #49

Accusing Jews of only caring about other Jews and madaboutharry Mar 18 #51

Lol. Sky Jewels Mar 19 #55

So my rhetorical question is: PCIntern Mar 16 #3

Israel will defend itself BannonsLiver Mar 16 #6

Yes...well it's a good thing that PCIntern Mar 16 #8

There is a big difference, and it's not "Jews" per se 0rganism Mar 16 #11

Cohen "....I blame Hamas for that." Ping Tung Mar 16 #4

This simply demands "one side" absorb all of the deaths of the innocents TheKentuckian Mar 16 #13

Strawman (nt) muriel_volestrangler Mar 16 #14

In what way? Totally on topic. TheKentuckian Mar 19 #73

A strawman is not something "off topic"; it's claiming something has happened when it hasn't muriel_volestrangler Mar 20 #78

Does you mean hat no dead Palistinians are innocents? Ping Tung Mar 16 #20

Some dead Palestinians are innocents. TheKentuckian Mar 18 #45

Collateral damage? Unfortunate circumstances? Ping Tung Mar 18 #50

Obviously collateral damage. TheKentuckian Mar 19 #69

Killing the many to kill the few? Ping Tung Mar 19 #70

The attacks must be stopped. Unconditional surrender ends wars. TheKentuckian Mar 19 #72

I'm with you on the attacks must be stopped. But I doubt that too many Ping Tung Mar 20 #76

Do you blame both sides for the attack on the Israeli civilians that started the war? Beastly Boy Mar 16 #18

When Israel had Intel of a potential attack a year in advance but dismissed it as big talk, elocs Mar 16 #32

I asked you whether you blame both sudes for the Hamas attacks on the Israeli civilians that started the war. Beastly Boy Mar 16 #34

I blame the killers on both sides for the deaths or maiming they do. Ping Tung Mar 16 #40

Next question: identify the killers on both sides who attacked Israeli civilians that started the war. Beastly Boy Mar 16 #41

If HAMAS hadn't ATTACKED Israel on Oct 7.. None of this would be Happening! Cha Mar 16 #28

K&R betsuni Mar 16 #7

Glazer's remarks were disgusting, disappointing, but oh so fucking predictable. Behind the Aegis Mar 16 #12

He condemned the Hamas attack muriel_volestrangler Mar 16 #15

Strawman (nt) Behind the Aegis Mar 16 #16

I asked you a question. So it's not a "strawman". muriel_volestrangler Mar 16 #17

Questions can be a Strawman. As well as the "loaded question" and the "accusatory question". Behind the Aegis Mar 16 #19

What were you calling "disgusting"? And, again, why was it "predictable"? How well did you know Glazer? (nt) muriel_volestrangler Mar 16 #21

His need to make that speech. Conflating. We had breakfast earlier. Behind the Aegis Mar 16 #22

What did he say at breakfast? muriel_volestrangler Mar 16 #23

I never kiss and tell. Behind the Aegis Mar 16 #24

Yeah, so it's just that you know that most Jews outside Israel think the Israeli attack has gone too far muriel_volestrangler Mar 16 #25

What color am I thinking of now? Behind the Aegis Mar 16 #27

You said you were able to know what Glazer was thinking before he said anything muriel_volestrangler Mar 16 #30

Disproportionate to what objective? Hamas is still there TheKentuckian Mar 18 #46

TY and Danny Cohen.. I agree with his statements. Cha Mar 16 #33

"the loss of civilian life is awful.." Ping Tung Mar 16 #42

None of this wold be Happening without the Fucking Butchers Cha Mar 16 #43

It was going on long before Hamas (who Netanyahu propped up to play 'divide et impera' games) existed. Celerity Mar 18 #54

And before that: Mosby Mar 19 #58

Tit for tat, back & forth, w/ Israel doing the vast amount of the killing & land taking over the sweep of last century. Celerity Mar 19 #65

If you have a better methodology for eliminating the threat TheKentuckian Mar 18 #47

I think an immediate cease fire should be called and arbitrators Ping Tung Mar 18 #52

A don't see the connection between a ceasefire and eliminating Hamas TheKentuckian Mar 19 #71

It's pretty hard to negotiate a peace and settlement while shooting at each other. Ping Tung Mar 20 #77

What "eye for an eye" method? Mosby Mar 19 #57

Hamas seems to be using the eye-for-eye method. Ping Tung Mar 19 #59

I took your advice and looked up eye for an eye. Ping Tung Mar 19 #60

Jews interpret and analyze the Torah for meanings. Mosby Mar 19 #61

If that's the case the Qu'ran and Bible say the same thing. Ping Tung Mar 19 #62

Ghandi was an antisemite who evinced the same lame colonial, imperial view as british amtisemites Mosby Mar 19 #63

Russian Marxist lies? Ping Tung Mar 19 #64

Einstein was a staunch Zionist, even befor WWII. Mosby Mar 19 #67

I'm not willing for anyone to die for anyone's beliefs. Ping Tung Mar 19 #68

You are free to have a personal suicide pact all you want TheKentuckian Mar 19 #74

You seem to be "intractable" and not a "better angel". Ping Tung Mar 20 #75

I don't disagree with Glazer. I thought it was a concise, nuanced speech. maxsolomon Mar 18 #48

It was very pretentious of him to claim his Jewishness to be hijacked. Beastly Boy Mar 18 #53

Curious if you've seen the film. maxsolomon Mar 19 #56

Glazer's speech was ridiculous. Elessar Zappa Mar 19 #66