General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: A way to purge the Supreme Court of the radical extremists: Impose a retirement age of 70. [View all]LostOne4Ever
(9,302 posts)These are what Id suggest
1) Every SC justice serves one AND ONLY ONE term.
2) Supreme Court terms last for a number of years equal to two times the total number of SC justices.
3) Terms are staggered such that a new judge would be appointed every 2 years with the appointment and confirmation of new judges being the very first thing congress must take up and finish before any other non-war time legislation.
4) Each judge must also nominate their own juniors (a first junior and a second) who would take their place should anything happen to the judge preventing them from doing their duties or finishing their term including death. These Juniors must be confirmed with the judge during the confirmation hearing. Should the first Junior have to permanently take over the term as the huge The first Junior is promoted to judge and the 2nd Junior is promoted to first Junior and the new judge must nominate a new second Junior.
5) Any judge that gets promoted to full judge is eligible for being nominated and appointed to a second term if and only if they served less than half of the original judges term.
6) The most senior judge on the SC would be the Supreme Justice with no judge allowed to take the position for more than one two year term.
7) Congress can void any ruling by the court if both houses can get a 55% majority vote and the presidents signature. OR a 60% majority vote of both houses. This is not a reversal so much as nullifying the ruling as though the case was never heard. The SC can rehear the case after two years time.
8) The president can force one case before the court of their choosing per year for a full hearing.
9) The court must decide on a code of ethics including situations where a judge must recuse themselves and situations warranting complete removal from the court by 2/3 or higher vote which must be approved by congress and the president before taking up any case.
[hr]
- - -
Reason why I suggest these specific suggestions beyond getting rid of radicals:
Since there are currently 9 justices the term would be 18 years, and if increased to 11 justices then they would all serve 22 years meaning 4 years would be added to each judges term. This would give EVERY congress a say in shaping the court and result in a court more representative of the American people and their votes.
Every president would get two nominees per term preventing situations like we had were Trump (a one termer) got 3 picks, as did Obama despite serving TWO terms, and Carter getting no picks.
It would prevent the court from being drastically changed just because a justice died for whatever reason. The will of the people would remain.
It would also add more checks and balances to the SC by both congress and the president and create a code of ethics the court must abide by.