Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ancianita

(36,383 posts)
23. Understood.
Mon Apr 29, 2024, 09:34 AM
Apr 29

Like members of SCOTUS, I am capable of talking through hypotheticals. I just not in a state right now where I can entertain the idea that they give us answers.

You're right. It is General Discussion, and indeed, you've discussed. While I appreciate your link to a valid definition of incompetence, I just think that, as far as this discussion relates to this former president, the courts won't go there.
So far, his lawyers haven't even brought up the idea, even if his incompetence seems apparent to millions.

IF they do, and some court finds him incompetent, these years of laying out his "private" v "official" acts will still stand as an historical learning experience for the country, in that it will show the lengths authoritarians will go to use the law and courts to stay in permanent power -- from stealing state secrets, lying, defaming, using government as a business for personal enrichment, purging political rivals from government, to using political violence. It will be an historical lesson to the nation on what secures and endangers Americans' freedom.

Thanks for your thoughts.

It all depends on the results of the next election calguy Apr 28 #1
and the results from the Supreme Court. gab13by13 Apr 28 #2
I feel confident the Supreme Court will rule against him as far as immunity goes calguy Apr 28 #4
Obviously Trump escapes accountability via stopping his own prosecution if he wins... Silent3 Apr 28 #3
I would think it unlikely... Ohio Joe Apr 28 #5
"...how likely is it Trump escapes accountability..." J_William_Ryan Apr 28 #6
This thread is *specifically about Trump being declared unfit to stand trial*... Silent3 Apr 28 #11
Why do people keep asking this ridiculous question? brooklynite Apr 28 #7
I'm talking about what happens if he's so clearly out of it... Silent3 Apr 28 #9
He will 100% escape accountability stumpysbear Apr 28 #8
This thread is *specifically about Trump being declared unfit to stand trial*... Silent3 Apr 28 #10
Not likely. He won't escape accountability in the Manhattan trial. Between May 31 & June 14 , the jury verdict will ancianita Apr 28 #12
I'd already set aside the current NY trial as too late for such an escape for Trump Silent3 Apr 29 #13
Look at Just Security, where I got my likely dates. This scheduling work is all they do, along with legal analysis. ancianita Apr 29 #14
You're still missing my point Silent3 Apr 29 #15
You're missing your own point. Your point that's derived from an IF is still hypothetical. ancianita Apr 29 #16
I guess you're one of those people who doesn't enjoy the mental exercise of hypothetical questions Silent3 Apr 29 #19
Understood. ancianita Apr 29 #23
he will not be declared mentally unfit by the courts, not even if his own attorneys try that angle (which he would Celerity Apr 29 #17
A person can reach a point where their behavior is so far gone... Silent3 Apr 29 #20
A year from now he may be POTUS again, so all the federal cases go away, & the state cases likely get put on hold. Celerity Apr 29 #22
I really want to be wrong KentuckyWoman Apr 29 #18
Concerning me is no_hypocrisy Apr 29 #21
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»For any Trump trials afte...»Reply #23