Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LymphocyteLover

(5,667 posts)
18. This is a big deal. Probably done in coordination with Biden
Thu Mar 14, 2024, 05:12 PM
Mar 14

from Josh Marshall--

"There was really quite a stunning development in the Senate this afternoon. Schumer went to the floor to call for new elections in Israel, calling Netanyahu “an obstacle to peace” and going on to say he is pursuing “dangerous and inflammatory policies that test existing standards for assistance.” If Netanyahu remains in power after the war, the US should “play a more active role in shaping Israeli policy by using our leverage to change the present course.”


...

First, it is not surprising that Schumer thinks this. It would very surprising if he didn’t. The fact that he is saying it on the Senate floor is truly stunning and something that in most cases would be all but unimaginable. The first and most obvious reason is that US leaders virtually never publicly call for new elections — and implicitly for a new government — in the governments of close allies. And for good reason.
...




The other really critical part of this is that Schumer is clearly running interference for Joe Biden and the policy shift he is trying to achieve. It is one clearly informed by the domestic situation in the United States. But it would be a basic error to reduce it to only that. To do so would be to ignore almost 15 years of relations between the Obama and Biden administrations — in and out of government. (Some are doing that out of ignorance, others for political purposes.) The White House has been signaling this pivot for weeks. Biden is a strong supporter of Israel going back literally half a century, though not of Netanyahu. He has also gone to great lengths, to his obvious political peril, to back Israel in recent months. But he’s still not Chuck Schumer. Schumer is Jewish and as the senior senator from New York comes from the cradle of American Jewry, New York City. Even today, with Jews decamped throughout the United States, New York City has the largest Jewish population of any city in the world, including Tel Aviv and Jerusalem.
...


Schumer is unquestionably taking this step in coordination with the White House. He is putting himself forward as a heat shield for Joe Biden. But it also clearly took an almost adamantine level of frustration and anger at Netanyahu to bring Schumer to this point. I have no doubt Schumer believes every word he is saying.



It’s a step that is an important one for US-Israel relations generally and also for American supporters of Israel generally."

Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) gives a "major address" on the Middle East, calling Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu to go LetMyPeopleVote Mar 14 #1
I support Senator Schumer 100%. patphil Mar 14 #8
Schumer's the smartest guy in the room, he's great Habitation Mar 14 #24
Senator Schumer went in hard speak easy Mar 14 #2
Is the dam starting to break? Basic LA Mar 14 #3
Chuck is correct. Happy Hoosier Mar 14 #4
Hell, yes! Bibi has to go. All the bloodshed is just to keep himself out of prison. PSPS Mar 14 #5
Post removed Post removed Mar 14 #6
No, he's not an Israeli citizen IronLionZion Mar 14 #12
Why don't we just have the CIA assassinate him? BWdem4life Mar 14 #7
Better late than never. TheRickles Mar 14 #9
Netanyahu destroys sympathy and goodwill for Israel IronLionZion Mar 14 #10
Schumer is an excellent example EllieBC Mar 14 #11
Everyone says Israel must change . . . Richard D Mar 14 #13
Get Arabs - Saudis - UAE to do the policing. speak easy Mar 14 #15
Good idea . . . Richard D Mar 14 #17
I can't find the link - maybe I dreamed it. speak easy Mar 14 #27
I hope so. Richard D Mar 14 #28
"Significant progress ... was looking possible and even likely prior to October 7" speak easy Mar 14 #29
a lasting peace only will come with a 2 state solution, which of course Netanyahu opposes LymphocyteLover Mar 14 #19
For all intents and purposes . . . Richard D Mar 14 #20
Netanyahu enabled hamas Habitation Mar 14 #25
Outstanding Enquiring_Mind Mar 14 #14
I think that's probably a good idea. I'll bet Biden would be relieved. Oopsie Daisy Mar 14 #16
This is a big deal. Probably done in coordination with Biden LymphocyteLover Mar 14 #18
Interesting opinion from an Israeli analyst. Mosby Mar 14 #21
Chuck is trying to walk some of it back Mosby Mar 14 #22
K&R ck4829 Mar 14 #23
But, Schumer, the government of Israel can do no wrong... Chainfire Mar 14 #26
Schumer is right! Hikerchick57 Mar 14 #30
Who knew... regnaD kciN Mar 14 #31
Kick dalton99a Mar 14 #32
political survival taking precedence? moondust Mar 15 #33
You'd have to be a moron to think LIHOP about October 7th Bucky Mar 15 #35
Maybe. moondust Mar 15 #40
I've read about that. That's why Israelis are furious with Netanyahu. But imagine the LIHOP alleged sequence of events. Bucky Mar 16 #42
can you decode your post for me....what's a lihop? prodigitalson Mar 15 #37
Let It Happen On Purpose moondust Mar 15 #38
thank you very mucho! prodigitalson Mar 15 #41
Good. mahina Mar 15 #34
apparently this got some attention Israel prodigitalson Mar 15 #36
Biden commends Schumer for his speech denouncing Netanyahu LetMyPeopleVote Mar 15 #39
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Chuck Schumer calls for n...»Reply #18