Reply #25: OK, I offer an alternative to what you're thinking. [View All]

I saw that in the preview for next week's episode, but I don't think Roslin is the final Cylon. It's possible, but I personally don't want to believe it. Consider this:

Here's what we know:
1. D'Anna knows who the final five are.
2. Editing can be used in a way to draw the audience to a conclusion that may or may not be true.

Here's what we don't know:
1. When D'Anna said "what you don't know is that you're one of them," whether or not she was talking directly to Roslin (D'Anna made that statement, cut, camera pans in on Roslin's face).

Instead of D'Anna telling Roslin that she's one of the final five (and really, why would they reveal that in an episode preview so early in the season?), I think one of the following things happened:
1. D'Anna may have been talking to Roslin, but may have told her she's one of the final five just to manipulate her for some unknown reason. We have no reason to believe that D'Anna was sincere when making that statement.
2. D'Anna may have been talking to a third person in the room, and the camera just panned in on Roslin's reaction. Aren't Tyrol and Anders on the ship with Roslin? D'Anna may have been talking to one of them.
3. That whole scene could have been part of one of Roslin's Kamala-induced visions. There's no way to know that it really happened.

So calm down and wait until Friday. The BSG creators are experts at teasing us to keep us tuned in, so I'm sure you will be surprised. :)

I'm just excited as hell that D'Anna is back!!!

:bounce: