Reply #12: She has as much a right to be in America as anyone. [View All]

Especially since she is an achiever. But even if she wasn't: Who cares where she was born? Does coming out of the right uterus make one special? No, it doesn't. If one argues that the special privilige of staying here is some sort of inherited birthright of anyone born on US soil, then one can as easily argue that anyone who is a decendent of white settlers should be convicted of genocide against the natives. Neither of these arguments makes sense, but since we have agreed that we can make up shit as we like, I can make up shit to counter shit.

Plus she was eight when she came over. She didn't break any laws.

I say we deport one of those anti-immigration white supremacist filth, and give her his citizenship. We need her. We don't need the teabaggers and the warcrime enablers.