It isn't an either/or, you know: there can be many children with ADHD while it is simultaneously over-diagnosed with medications being over-prescribed. Anyone who has worked with students or children in this age group has seen many cases of BOTH scenarios.
Neither your generalized, blanket statements ("ADHD does not exist") or your tear jerking, overly-emotional anecdotes manage to effectively address the real issues: figuring the causes for the syndrome (please note, it is NOT a disease: the concept of a "cure" doesn't really apply -- it is a developmental disorder. Early Childhood educators should know and understand the difference.) while simultaneously working against Big Pharma's move to medicate every child on the planet.
Did you know there are doctors around the nation who diagnose ADHD while the child is still in the womb? It's true and a growing practice; if the fetus is jumpy or lively, the child MUST be ADHD. You do understand that every case of hyperactivity and refusal to obey is NOT automatically ADHD, don't you? It is NOT one or the other: ADHD is both a real developmental disorder AND it is radically over-treated with improperly prescribed psycho-pharmaceutical drugs.
http://www.srmhp.org/0201/adhd.htmlThe Scientific Review of Mental Health Practice
SRMHP Home / Spring ~ Summer 2003 Volume 2 Number 1 /
ADHD among American Schoolchildren
Evidence of Overdiagnosis and Overuse of Medication
Authors:
Gretchen B. LeFever and Andrea P. Arcona - Center for Pediatric Research, Eastern Virginia Medical School and Children's Hospital of the King's Daughters
David O. Antonuccio - University of Nevada School of Medicine, Veterans Affairs Sierra Nevada Health Care System.
Author Note:
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Gretchen B. LeFever, Ph.D., Old Dominion University and Safety and Learning Solutions, 912 Queen Elizabeth Drive, Virginia Beach, VA 23452, gblefever@gmail.com.
Abstract:
The 700% increase in psychostimulant use that occurred in the 1990s justifies concern about potential overdiagnosis and inappropriate treatment of child behavior problems. A critical review of epidemiologic research suggests that attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is not universally overdiagnosed; however, for some U.S. communities there is evidence of substantial ADHD overdiagnosis, adverse educational outcomes among children treated for the disorder, and suboptimal management of childhood behavior problems. Evidence of ADHD overdiagnosis is obscured when findings are reported without respect to geographic location, race, gender, and age. More sophisticated epidemiologic tracking of ADHD treatment trends and examination of associated outcomes is needed to appreciate the scope of the problem on a national level. Meanwhile, a public health approach to ADHD that includes the development and implementation of data-driven, community-based interventions is warranted and is underway in some communities. Guidelines for promoting judicious use of psychotropic drugs are suggested.