End Times
The Bushies may be accomplishing what liberals never could: bringing the era of conservative morality to a close.
By Michael Tomasky
Web Exclusive: 05.17.04
http://www.prospect.org/web/page.ww?section=root&name=ViewWeb&articleId=7739We aren't witnessing just the disastrous meltdown of Bush administration policy in Iraq. Nor are we witnessing merely the potential end of the line for one Cabinet official, although it does seem possible that, in the wake of Sy Hersh's devastating New Yorker take-out this week, George W. Bush will downgrade his assessment of Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld from "superb" to "expendable" (with the president now within the margin of error of approval ratings in high 30's, he desperately needs to roll a head that will make a statement).
Those developments, important as they are, don't really show us the big picture. The meta-story here is we are watching the total collapse of conservative morality.
Liberals and conservatives, as George Lakoff and others have observed, operate according to distinct moral systems. Lakoff's research has tended to emphasize the moral universes of individual liberals and conservatives -- liberals believe in questioning authority, conservatives believe in respecting authority, that sort of thing.
But the differences in the two moral systems also play out on the social or civic plane, and not just the individual level. And in that civic sphere, the differences come down to this. Liberals believe in public morality and in adherence to democratic process, while conservatives value personal morality and positive, efficiently achieved results. What has happened at Abu Ghraib -- and in Iraq generally -- are in fact direct expressions of conservative morality unchecked.
And it's clearer every week that conservative morality is a contradiction in terms, and that the American people are coming around to that view. I think this theory explains -- well, basically everything. For example: How many conversations have you had with a fellow liberal, discussing the latest administration effrontery, that concluded with one of you asking the other some version of, "How can it possibly be that this isn't considered a scandal?!"