|
The very idea that there's worse is damaging. Now that we already know that, they may as well release it.
In a more subtle way, Rummy is trying to blame the troops for these atrocities. To a certain extent, that is true. However, as a veteran (who held an MI MOS, no less), I know that doesn't cover it. Putting a troop on the spot by giving illegal orders may put the soldier at risk if those orders are obeyed, but it certainly does not exonerate the commander who issued them. On the contrary, military discipline requires that harsher penalties be given to those in command.
This problem goes all the way to the top. It is Bush and his people who instituted a system of justice after September 11 that is designed to circumvent the Third Geneva Conventions. Prisoners have no rights or human dignity. They are dismissed as "illegal combatants", a term not found in any document of international law; in direct contradiction to the Geneva Convention, which mandates that any combat detainee shall be treated as a prisoner of war until a competent court decides the status, the status of the detainee is left to the President and the Secretary of Defense. In Guantanamo, detainees are housed in 6' x 8' x 8' cages. In addition, torture is expressly prohibited by the Geneva Conventions and other international treaties and conventions to which the US is a party; yet the Bush administration has made torture a weapon in the war on terror. Before Abu Ghraib, there were documented cases of US sending a detainee to a third country with a less than stellar human rights record where the interrogant is to be tortured. This practice is expressly prohibited by the 1984 Convention against Torture.
Perhaps with the exposure of Abu Ghraib, Bush's America need not be so squeamish about farming out torture to Mubarak or King Abdallah. The human rights record of this administration is as sufficiently abominable that they should be able to handle it themselves. The only problem for them is that now that their practices have been exposed to daylight, the American people will not permit it.
The focus should not be on the troops. The focus should be on the responsibility of the administration which has created an atmosphere of contempt for international humanitarian laws and conventions that lead commanders to believe that abhorrent practices are tolerated and sanctioned and for enlisted men and women to believe that orders such as those given at Abu Ghraib are lawful.
This is not just lax oversight of rogue elements in the military and the intelligence community. This is official policy.
We are talking about war crimes and crimes against humanity. We are talking about them on a wide scale. We are talking about holding those at the top responsible for them.
We, the American people, cannot return Bush to power. We would dishonor ourselves to do so now, in light of this. He must be removed at the earliest opportunity and held to account for his misdeeds.
|