I think this argument kind of diminishs the experience of those at Abu Ghraib Prison. There could be vast improvements in the American criminal justice system, particularly in the area of race relations (not sure what to call it, but I assume you know what I mean). I'm not sure what's wrong with using police dogs, incidently; they provide a valuable service.
But the abuses in America take place in a framework that condemns them; the system is set up such that while offenses do occur, they can be dealt with, at least in theory.
The prisoners in Abu Ghraib did not have that. There was no system of law that they could rely on. All they had was the good will of the Americans, and everyday they were presented with evidence that such good will did not exist.
To sum up--I think that both the Abu Ghraib Prison scandal, and abuses in the American Legal Systems are serious problems, but they are seperate and distinct problems.
Bryant
Check it out -->
http://politicalcomment.blogspot.com