Fox News Watch panelist Gabler: Fox News "pumping" Christmas "war"
Media writer Neil Gabler, a regular
Fox news panelist, asserted that Fox News hosts Bill O'Reilly, Sean Hannity, and John Gibson are "demagogues" who seek to "rally the masses" with their talk of a purported effort to suppress public recognition of the Christmas holiday. On the December 3 edition of Fox News Watch, Gabler said of those making such accusations: "They'll do it every Christmas. They did it last Christmas; they'll do it next Christmas." Later in the segment, Gabler stated: "The media, particularly Fox media, has been pumping the hell out of this thing."
Gabler's comments came during a segment that an off-screen announcer previewed by asking, "Is there a Grinch taking the holly jolly out of Christmas? Why has this holy season become a target of the liberal media?" Early in the discussion, Gabler remarked that the battle over public acknowledgement of Christmas "is being called a war ... in certain places." During the segment, American University professor and Fox News contributor Jane Hall specifically criticized O'Reilly and Gibson for their emphasis of the issue:
From the December 3 edition of Fox News Watch:
GABLER: Now let's talk about the elephant in the room; let's talk about the media.
BURNS: Just a minute, Neal; if it started in 1921 --
GABLER: It's not a story.
BURNS: If I can just --
GABLER: It was a demagogic campaign.
BURNS: If I can just give three examples right now in different parts of the country --
GABLER: We're 300 million people. You know, I can give you --
BURNS: But there are -- just a minute, there are more than three examples to give --
GABLER: Three incidents of chicken pox doesn't make an epidemic.
HALL: But what is the media -- where is the media angle?
GABLER: The media angle right here -- Look, I want to talk about the media angle, because we've avoided it; it's the elephant in the room -- it's Fox News. Come on. It's O'Reilly; it's Hannity; it's Gibson. They're demagogues who realize that at Christmastime, you can -- you can --
GABLER: You rally the masses on this issue.
GABLER: They'll do it every Christmas. They did it last Christmas; they'll do it next Christmas.
BURNS: I spend this whole show sitting back most of the time. I don't think it is demagoguery to point out that there are people who are themselves being demagogues by trying to take away the worship terminology of 95 percent of Americans.
GABLER: Eric, we are at war. There's the humanitarian crisis in Darfur. There's an AIDS crisis. And you're worried about whether people are saying "Merry Christmas" or not?BURNS: No.
GABLER: What world do you live in?BURNS: Hey, Neal, it's one issue, and it's the issue that's the subject of this top -- that's the subject of this segment.
GABLER: And the media have been pumping it, and that's my point.
PINKERTON: All right.
GABLER: The media, particularly Fox media, has been pumping the hell out of this thing.http://mediamatters.org/items/200512060002Better clean out your desk, Neal...your gig at FAUX is about to expire...