http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=105x9298627I'm counting as "dead" people that we saw die, or were confirmed to be dead on the main timeline of the show. In other words, not everyone in the church will be considered dead.
My score:
Right: Sawyer, Sayid, Widmore, Ilana, WTFlocke, Christian Shepherd, Kate, Mr. Paik, Hurley, Bernard, Rose, WAAALT, Charlie (the baby), Aaron, Ji Yeon, and Vincent.
Wrong: Claire, Ben, Richard, Miles, Frank Lapidus, Jack, Jin, and Sun
I didn't take a guess on Desmond or Penny, and I was 0/2 about who would succeed Jacob.
I got 66% right, and missed the bonus question.
SoxFan's guess:
Right: Widmore, Jin, Kate, Hurley, Desmond, Penny, Sayid, and Vincent.
Wrong: Claire, Richard, Sawyer, Ben, Rose, Bernard, Miles, Hawking, Lapidus, Paik, baby Charlie, Ji Yeon, Jack, and Sun.
He got 36% right, and he didn't take a guess on Jacob's successor.
OhioJoe's guess:
Right: Jack, Sayid, Jin, Bernard, Rose, Walt, Desmond, Penny, Widmore, Ilana, Christian Shepherd, baby Charlie, Aaron, and Ji Yeon.
Wrong: Kate, Sawyer, Sun, Claire, Richard, Miles, Lapidus, Paik, and Vincent.
Interesting, and partly right: Hurley lives and leaves the island, and Ben lives and becomes the new Smokey.
Interesting, but also wrong: Sun lives and becomes the new Jacob, and Smokey lives on in Ben.
He got 59% right, and was wrong about the next Jacob.
Bucky's guess:
Right: Jack, Kate, Sawyer, and Miles.
Wrong: Rose and Bernard
Both at the same time: "Hurley is totally dead meat. The original description for the character was "red shirt". If he does live, he's the new Jacob."
Interesting but wrong: Kate ends up with Miles instead of Sawyer.
He got 66% right, and called it on Hurley.
Miles Coltrane's guess:
Right: Kate, Hurley, Sayid, Bernard, Rose, Walt, Desmond, Penny, Widmore, Lapidus, Ilana, WTFlocke, Christian, Paik, Aaron, Ji Yeon, and Vincent.
Wrong: Jack, Sawyer, Jin, Sun, Claire, Ben, Richard, and Miles.
He got 68% right and didn't have a guess for the new Jacob.
Bucky for round 2:
Right: Penny, Desmond, Charlie Hume, Paik, Aaron, Ji Yeon, Walt, Miles, Claire, Kate, Lapidus, Christian, Jack, Sayid, and Ilana.
Wrong: Jin, Sun, Rose, Bernard, Widmore, WTFlocke, Richard, Hurley, and Ben.
No guess: Sawyer
He got 62% right and didn't stick with his original Hurley guess.
mainstreetonce's guess:
Right: Kate, Sayid, Sun, Claire, Bernard, Rose, Walt, Desmond, Widmore, Ilana, Miles, Lapidus, WTFlocke, Christian, Paik, Charlie, Aaron, Ji Yeon, and Vincent.
Wrong: Jack, Hurley, Sawyer, Jin, Penny, Ben, Richard, David, and Original Recipe Locke.
He (or she?) got 67% right, and didn't guess about the new Jacob.
Miles Coltrane was the winner! :party: