|
That claim rests on an assumption of a binary pairing - Republicans on one "side" of linear single-axis political line and "Democrats" on the other. It assumes that public reaction to both is identical, among other assumptions.
The trouble with this idea is that, when political names are left out, polls consistently show that the public favors many so-called "liberal" ideas by large margins. They do not favor the ideas that the Republican party is no running toward. They do favor the ideas that liberals want to see the Democratic party more fully embrace.
Why don't they they? Quite simply because the Democratic party is constrained by massive, powerful lobbying interests - namely corporate interests, but also the interests of some foreign countries. Similarly the Republican party, is constrained by corporate interests - but it has a more dangerous contraint that increases its rapid marginalization - its ultra-conservative masssive fundraising block.
Comparison between the ultra rights wildly unpopular views (they only win when those views are masked and subtley woven into some larger more publicly acceptable narrative) and Liberals far more popular views is really not a fair comparison at all.
Additionally, there are varying degrees of the size of one's "tent." Right now the republicans are making the mistake of wanting a party so tiny, that only a fraction of the public will have any interest in it. By contrast, the Democratic party's mistake is exactly the opposite. By its race to expand the tent to a size where virtually everyone is "welcome" regardless of their positions on anything, Democrats become meaningless. They also sacrifice their ability to get things done.
Just because the republicans are going "too small" doesn't mean that the Democratic party hasn't been going "too big." What's needed is to strike the right balance between agreement on party essentials and freedom in party non-essentials. But of course the Democrats have never defined any set of essentials and thus they wander around like a disjointed directionless mass and the wonder why they have so much more trouble getting things done than their Republican counterparts did when they were functioning like a well-oiled machine.
|