John Nichols: Paul Ryan's 'Lord of the Flies' agenda
John Nichols — 5/25/2008 7:11 am
Wisconsin Congressman Paul Ryan is getting lots of attention for his sweeping proposal to "reform" the federal government. Unfortunately, the Janesville Republican fails to recognize the difference between reforming institutions and wrecking them.
Ryan's "Road Map for America's Future" is really a proposal that -- if implemented -- would drive this country off the cliff into a "Lord of the Flies" future where pursuit of the common good -- which Americans have been so successful in advancing when they have worked together under the leadership of Democratic presidents such as Franklin Roosevelt and John Kennedy and Republicans such as Dwight Eisenhower and Gerald Ford -- is sacrificed in a grab-all-you-can-for-yourself race to the bottom.Of course, Ryan does not expect his program to be implemented in its entirety.
He is smart enough to know that this would turn Americans against his Republican Party with a fervor not seen since the days when voters ran Herbert Hoover out of the White House.
Ryan's game is a more cynical one. He wants to promote privatization schemes that maintain bulky government bureaucracies while steering hundreds of billions of federal dollars into the accounts of financial, insurance and health care corporations that will kick back some of the money in the form of campaign contributions.
Ryan's purpose is to make the rich dramatically richer -- by cutting their taxes and making it easier for them to opt out of universal programs -- while making it easier for for-profit companies to pocket federal money that is allocated to maintain Medicare, Social Security and other safety net programs.
The congressman may use more market-friendly terms to describe his "reforms." But Ryan's plan is really just a warmed-over package of Washington "think tank" schemes for privatizing programs, cutting taxes for the rich, and undermining protections for the vast majority of Americans.
As one of Ryan's challengers this year, Democrat Paulette Garin, says of Ryan's road map: "It's just the same old GOP strategy to demonize taxes and attract voters when in reality the plan will most likely only benefit the wealthiest amongst us."
Garin's right. Ryan's not proposing reforms. And he is certainly not suggesting anything that could, by even the widest stretch, be defined as "fiscally conservative."
The ambitious congressman is attacking government with the purpose of advancing his own political prospects -- both as a rising Republican leader in Congress and as a potential running mate for presumptive presidential nominee John McCain.
The sad thing about Ryan's proposal is that this able young legislator could have advanced smart proposals that hold the line on taxes for the great majority of Americans while preserving the safety net and encouraging innovation. Instead, he's peddling a redistribute-the-wealth-upward plan to make it easier for the big guys to push the rest of us around.
http://www.madison.com/tct/column/288084