Mods, this is another column by my friend, Don Williams. I called him today and he has given me permission to post this in its entirety since The Knoxville News-Sentinel
is subscription only.By Don WilliamsLast Friday I addressed a group of Democrats in a Blount County cafeteria, and standing there amid some 50 or so finishing their coffee and iced tea and apple pie, I satisfied my curiosity about something: "How many of you believe Bush stole the 2004 election?" I asked.
I was surprised when at least two-thirds immediately raised their hands. Ask the same question to a room full of Republicans, and you'll get hooted off the floor. It's a sign of the times. These days what you know or think you know depends on who you tune in.
The 2004 election is a perfect example. It may or may not surprise you, depending on where you get your news, to learn there were demonstrations, lawsuits, recounts and hearings in Ohio, Washington State, Washington, D.C., and elsewhere about the irregular voting patterns that gave us four more years of George W. Bush.
You likely heard little about those activities unless you checked Internet sources. On the day Rep. John Conyers held hearings on such matters, they hardly made the evening news.
Still, the good folks who raised their hands in the Blount County cafeteria had reason to be suspicious of this election. After all, no media had taken much trouble to alleviate their fears. The networks and cable mostly ignored, hooted down or offered dubious explanations for voter anomalies.
But these were not trivial.
First of all, exit polls predicted a substantial Kerry victory. Even conservative Fox News loudly acknowledges that discrepancy in a mocking way. Our government often regards discrepancies between exit polls and official tallies in other countries as signs of voter fraud. I've heard no convincing reason from the media or government for the difference here. So I wonder about it, especially given the 2000 election debacle.
The January issue of Harper's magazine lists several other reasons - some anecdotal, some more telling - why we should be concerned about the state of our democracy.
# For example, a Franklin, Ohio, precinct possessed of 638 voters at first awarded 4,258 votes to Bush.
# In 47 of 67 counties in Florida, Bush got more votes than there were registered Republicans.
# Of the 120 million-plus votes cast nationwide, about one-third were on voting machines provided by private corporations. At least one of them - Diebold - was under control of a zealous Republican CEO who promised to deliver Ohio to Bush.
# In Illinois, Maine and Wisconsin, states that relied mostly on paper ballots, exit polls agreed with the final tally. In North Carolina, New Hampshire, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, Florida and Ohio, which relied much more heavily on electronic touch screens, the discrepancy between exit polls and the final tally invariably favored Bush.
# In 10 of 11 swing states, the final result differed from the predicted result, and in all 10 of those states, the shift added votes for Bush.
# Voters in six states reported touching the screen for Kerry and seeing their ballots marked for Bush.
None of this was conclusive proof of a stolen election, but it should've been enough to spark in-depth stories by the media. We should know beyond doubt who controls the software in touch-screen machines. Is it foolproof? I don't know. I suspect you don't either. Such ignorance and press indifference bodes ill for the future of our democracy.
I wouldn't bring up the negligent post-election coverage if the media had not let us down lately in so many ways. Several news organs apologized for not being more skeptical of the Bush claims about weapons of mass destruction and al-Qaida connections and Saddam's alleged ties to 9/11 and the costs of waging war in Iraq.
If big media led us astray on Iraq - and they admit they did - isn't it possible they also blew the election coverage? To many of the good folks I spoke to in Blount County last week, it isn't a close call.
Don Williams is the founding editor of New Millennium Writings. You may write to him at PO Box 2463, Knoxville, TN., 37901, e-mail him at donwilliams7@charter.net.
Copyright 2005, Knoxville News Sentinel Co.
http://knoxnews.com/kns/opinion_columnists/article/0,1406,KNS_364_3468898,00.html