http://www.truthdig.com/dig/item/religion_homosexualityInventing Sin: Religion and Homosexuality
No matter their own scandals, religious institutions through history have a consistent scapegoat: homosexuals.A Dig led by Larry Gross
Dig posted on Dec. 1, 2005
(snip - article begins with several recent examples of denouncement of male homosexuality by spokepeople for major religions)These apparently disparate events reflect a current reality: At the start of the 21st century, religion remains intertwined with politics, and few topics arouse as much religious fervor as those concerned with sexuality-as we are witnessing in the battle today over gay marriage. Indeed, for the three Abrahamic religions, as they’re sometimes called, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, homosexuality has provided a rare example of a truly common cause-the unusually harsh and virulent condemnation of homosexuality by religious authorities through the ages.
In nearly all societies throughout human history, religion offers answers to fundamental questions concerning the origin and meaning of things. Religious systems of explanation offer accounts of the creation of the world, as well as specifying the rules for proper behavior-and the consequences for infractions-that have been imposed by the Creator. In “Civilization and Its Discontents,” Freud summarized what “the common man understands by his religion-the system of doctrines and promises which on the one hand explains to him the riddle of life with enviable completeness, and, on the other, assures him that a careful Providence will watch over his life and will compensate him in a future life for any frustrations he suffers here.”
In Western culture, the dominant religious traditions for the past two millenniums have been Christian, built upon, but significantly differing from, Judaism. In contrast to most other major world religions-Hinduism, Buddhism, Confucianism and Islam-Christianity has been marked by what sex historian Vern L. Bullough terms a general antagonism toward sexual expression. However, homosexuality has been singled out in Judaism and Christianity for condemnation far greater than that directed toward most other forms of sexual behavior.
Old Testament views on sexuality were shaped by principles that resulted in hostility to homosexual acts. The first was a focus on procreation as a necessary goal and duty, embodied in the commandment to “be fruitful and multiply.” This fundamental injunction led to the expectation that everyone would marry as early as possible and engage in marital sexual intercourse on a regular basis. In this context, any sexual act that could not promote appropriate procreation was sinful. Thus, because conception was viewed as the product of male semen planted in the female womb, lesbianism did not evoke the same sort of condemnation: As one Biblical scholar put it, “In lesbianism there is no spilling of seed. Thus life is not symbolically lost, and therefore lesbianism is not prohibited in the Bible.”
(snip - MUCH more at link; this is a long article) By the way, TruthDig (along with the SF Chronicle) is where Robert Scheer is now devoting his insight and energies since he was replaced at the LA Times with a mealy-mouthed wingnut. You'll see articles by him under the banner "Ear to the Ground" on the right side of the TruthDig home page:
http://www.truthdig.comEdited to add: I have cross-posted to Progressive Independent here:
http://www.progressiveindependent.com/dc/dcboard.php?az=show_mesg&forum=127&topic_id=1343&mesg_id=1343and, in an attempt to draw in more discussion to this current GLBT thread, have posted brief headsup crossposts in the DU Religion/Theology forum
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=214x38711and the General Discussion forum
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=104x5509819I'd like to see a full, rich, insightful discussion by people with a range of viewpoints and information to offer.