The Nation: The Disappearing Upper Class

The Disappearing Upper Class
posted by Zephyr Teachout on 05/15/2008 @ 3:40pm



Edwards, it is hoped, will bring the "working class" vote to Obama. In alternative descriptions, he will help with the "middle class" vote; or what a very tired Clinton might call the "white-middle white-class, white-working, white-vote." This (disappearing) working class population fills the pages of analysis and news. In the New York Times, for example, there are 324 references to "middle class," and 220 references to "working class" in the last three months.

At the same time, the "upper class" is vanishing from our language. In the 18 references in the New York Times in the last three months, none are in the context of elections. "Upper class" appears most in quotes, literature review and history, or as a referent to people on the other side of the puddle, as they say, the "upper-class British" way of life appears, as does the "upper-class European" and the upper class voice of a deceased BBC announcer.

In America, we don't have the upper class, apparently. We have, according to many news reports, "elites." There are thousands of references to elites; in the context of politics, a search for "Clinton" and "elite" in the last three months finds 40 results while the blogs are full of concern about various candidates' tendencies to attract elite voters. It sounds like an epithet, when thrown at campaign managers ("you are just getting the elite vote"), but it's a compliment to the people described therein.

"Elites only, folks, elites only for early boarding" cries the Continental Airline steward, and the rich people line up, complimented and convenienced at the same time. The best football players are elite, and the best colleges are elite--the word comes not with the stink of privilege but with the flattering sound of being something deserved, worked for even. Elites may be "out of touch," but they are "out of touch" with a french-derived word meaning to choose--the same root as the word "election," as it turns out. The elite are the chosen, the secular "good men and women", ones we ought make way for as they pass. ......(more)

The complete piece is at: http://www.thenation.com/blogs/passingthrough/321232

Or its derivations. "High earning," "high-income."

"High income" probably most of all. Today's bunch don't have all that much class.