I don't blame teachers for being upset about this issue. Perdido Street School blog has a passionate post up on the topic.
Criticism of Race to the Top bonus moneyUnbelievable - in the very same week Mulgrew and the UFT tell us we have to change teacher evaluation rules and tie them to test scores because "this is the wave of the future," the push back against Race to the Top is reaching a crescendo - against the Obama plan!!!
..."The UFT and the NYSUT could have argued that adding more tests to public education - as the new teacher evaluation rules will do - is harmful to children and schools and they would have gotten some pretty good backing from across the country as people push back against Obama, Duncan and the administration's merry band of Gates Foundation shills.
But instead the UFT and the NYSUT caved and gave up the ghost on test scores - now you can be sure that additional tests will be added to EVERY subject in EVERY grade, teachers will ONLY teach to the test as they try and save their jobs from whatever bullshit "value-added" formula Klein, Steiner and Tisch pull out of their corrupt asses, and the only people who will be happy about this are Obama, Duncan, the eduwankers in and out of the administration and the test prep companies who stand to make billions off the changes.
And this did NOT have to be. The tide is turning AGAINST Obama and Race to the Top
Here is the comment on how NY teachers were screwed by their unions.
But too late for we here in New York.
The UFT and the NYSUT have already caved to Obama and his eduwankers.
Very, very infuriating.
Here is the Politico article to which the blogger links.
Race to the Top is hitting the wall.President Barack Obama’s $4.35 billion grant competition — designed to encourage states to dramatically improve school performance — is running into resistance across the country, as state officials and teachers unions are clashing with the administration over the contest rules.
And now Congress is getting into the act — with lawmakers of both parties challenging the president’s tough-love approach to school improvement. Duncan has $3.4 billion left to award. But Indiana dropped its second application, after a very public spat between its public school chief and teachers unions. Vermont decided the competition wasn’t moving the state in the right direction. The Kansas State Board of Education concluded that the federal guidelines were at odds with Kansas’s culture of local control, making their chances of winning zilch. Alaska and Texas didn’t bother applying the first time.
Teachers unions — usually stalwart Democratic supporters — are staging boycotts. The Massachusetts branch of the American Federation of Teachers shunned its state’s second application because it was fed up with being blamed for underperforming schools. The Colorado Education Association, a National Education Association affiliate, also withdrew its support because it felt the state’s education commissioner had thrown teachers under the bus.
“Bottom line, I have never seen a school turn around or do better with this kind of friction,” AFT President Randi Weingarten said. “That’s the status quo. The status quo is to point fingers.”
Trouble is not enough teachers unions are standing up for their members. And most not forcefully enough.
Diane Ravitch recently said that
"Race to the Top has ignited an outburst of meanness"It truly has. It has turned parents and teachers and students against each other, it has divided Democrats within the party.
New York seems hard hit by the new school "reforms", which are not reforms at all. They don't fix anything, they don't even claim to do so....they just want to turn struggling schools around..."turnarounds". They don't want to fix them, they want to fire the principals and teachers or turn them into charter schools run by private companies.
Even with the huge number of layoffs of teachers there, the state DOE wants 5 million to go out and
recruit more teachers....new ones, cheaper ones. Ones with less experience.
I don't really agree that the tide is turning against Arne's bribes to states and districts to do things his way.
I think there may be a stirring of unrest, and that is all so far.
I think far too many are willing to go along because the Democrats are doing it. When Gingrich and George and Jeb wanted to do the same things....there was someone to fight them.
Now there is no opposition of which to speak as public schools are being "turned around", closed, or handed to the private sector on a silver platter.