on the CBS video"
I'm getting tired of all this "Coast Guard under 'BP control'" crap based on the CBS videohttp://demopedia.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=389x8392701If you watch the video and listen to the reporter, she says "a boat of BP contractors with two Coast Guard officers on board, told us to turn around under threat of arrest."
She's not saying the boat is a coast guard boat, as I'm seeing some DU'ers now start claiming, and it obviously isn't. As well, if you look at the people on the boat it appears the coast guard officers are standing in the rear...the guy leaning out the window who says "these are BP rules, not ours" is almost certainly not even a coast guard officer. Watch the video.
The coast guard has responded, according to
Rawstory, as follows:
------------------------------------
"The only time anyone would be asked to move from an area would be if there were safety concerns, or they were interfering with response operations. This did occur off South Pass Monday which may have caused the confusion reported by CBS today."
http://rawstory.com/rs/2010/0520/coast-guard-bps-rules-------------------------------------------
And the Coast Guard has also clearly stated who's in charge. From
AP:-----------------------------------------
"That sense of frustration is shared by an increasing number of Gulf Coast residents, elected officials and environmental groups who have called for the government to simply take over.
In fact, the government is overseeing things. But the official responsible for that says he still understands the discontent.
"If anybody is frustrated with this response, I would tell them their symptoms are normal, because I'm frustrated, too," said Coast Guard Commandant Thad Allen."
....
He and Coast Guard Adm. Mary Landry, the federal onsite coordinator, direct virtually everything BP does in response to the spill — and with a few exceptions have received full cooperation, Allen said.
White House press secretary Robert Gibbs was even more emphatic.
"There's nothing that we think can and should be done that isn't being done. Nothing," Gibbs said Friday during a lengthy, often testy exchange with reporters about the response to the oil disaster.
There are no powers of intervention that the federal government has available but has opted not to use, Gibbs said.
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/us_gulf_oil_spill_bp_in_charge-------------------------------------------
What you have is some contractor on a non-government boat telling a news crew to stay away from a beach under the auspices of "BP rules" and there happens to be two coast officers on board. I assume the officers were the ones who threatened arrest...we don't see that on video (strangely), but if the beach should not have boats coming to shore because there's oil on it and a boat driving a wedge into the sand could hamper clean up efforts or WHATEVER, then the order makes sense.
What we DON'T have here is a takeover of the coast guard by BP, or a "media blackout" of a BP coast guard takeover, or any real evidence of anything of the sort. There's just no evidence of it.
I think CBS did a crappy job on this report. The reporter didn't bother to clarify why they were being kept from the beach...leaving all the conspiracy theists to assume it's so the oil can't be filmed. As if everyone's not already seeing the oil, and as if the oil couldn't be seem from their boat. The idea that BP would commandeer coast guard officers to chase around in an effort to hide oil from the media is beyond ludicrous.
alright, i'm done.