Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)What Is Really Going On at Columbia University? [View all]
From Slate, an interview with the current editor of the student newspaper, Colin Roedl and the former editor, Milène Klein, on what is going on at Columbia. They paint a different picture than the frenzied media reporting and internet postings here and elsewhere.
Aymann Ismail (interviewer): What is the mood on campus right now?
Milène Klein: Actually, pretty good. Were in the newsroom right now. The mood on campus is actually high. Theres a lot of energy. People are chilling on the lawns.
This weekend is the first time the NYPD had been called to actually break up a protest. There had already been arrests around campus, if not actually on campus, so I think many people are very distressed and extremely disappointedbut not surprised. The university introduced security forces to disrupt peaceful protest simply because they want to appease the people who are watching the congressional hearings and who are asking questions in bad faith. This is the audience they are kowtowing to. I think thats what people are more distressed by than the police presence, to be honest.
Roedl: Actively calling for more police contributes to feelings of unsafety. And those feelings of unsafety are contributing to more police. So were seeing a feedback loop with absolutely no communication from our administration. That is the uniting point for a lot of people, regardless of politics, that were seeing complete silence from our administration. They made the decision to authorize NYPD on campus, and thats the last time we have heard from her.
Klein: Theres a lot of discussion about what is happening at Columbia campus. Like, Theres crisis at Columbiayou have this image of students hunting each other in the street, like absolute chaos. There are alarmists framing this all around antisemitism, or a crusade against Jewish students, whom are hiding or being pushed out of campus. I dont think any of us have seen that. The reality is that were a community of people who live together, eat together, and go to class together every single day. And for people who want to hear what Columbia students have to say, you have to read what theyre saying in their own words.
Milène Klein: Actually, pretty good. Were in the newsroom right now. The mood on campus is actually high. Theres a lot of energy. People are chilling on the lawns.
This weekend is the first time the NYPD had been called to actually break up a protest. There had already been arrests around campus, if not actually on campus, so I think many people are very distressed and extremely disappointedbut not surprised. The university introduced security forces to disrupt peaceful protest simply because they want to appease the people who are watching the congressional hearings and who are asking questions in bad faith. This is the audience they are kowtowing to. I think thats what people are more distressed by than the police presence, to be honest.
Roedl: Actively calling for more police contributes to feelings of unsafety. And those feelings of unsafety are contributing to more police. So were seeing a feedback loop with absolutely no communication from our administration. That is the uniting point for a lot of people, regardless of politics, that were seeing complete silence from our administration. They made the decision to authorize NYPD on campus, and thats the last time we have heard from her.
Klein: Theres a lot of discussion about what is happening at Columbia campus. Like, Theres crisis at Columbiayou have this image of students hunting each other in the street, like absolute chaos. There are alarmists framing this all around antisemitism, or a crusade against Jewish students, whom are hiding or being pushed out of campus. I dont think any of us have seen that. The reality is that were a community of people who live together, eat together, and go to class together every single day. And for people who want to hear what Columbia students have to say, you have to read what theyre saying in their own words.
https://slate.com/human-interest/2024/04/columbia-university-protests-presidents-jewish-students-encampment.html
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
102 replies, 5054 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (31)
ReplyReply to this post
102 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
They'd better be more vocal about that. Or separate themselves from agitators as much as they can.
shrike3
Apr 23
#6
Most of us can differentiate between antisemitism and protesting the actions of a sovereign country.
shrike3
Apr 23
#7
I was locked out during the Great Hack of 2016. Read for a few years, then rejoined in 2020.
shrike3
Apr 23
#9
"How is "Go Back to Poland" not antisemitic?" -- this is an outside group, and not on campus
obamanut2012
Apr 23
#11
The fact that it's coming from people who don't go to the university doesn't make it okay.
shrike3
Apr 23
#19
I would bet money on the notion that everyone on this website thinks that statement is anti Semitic
ExciteBike66
Apr 23
#41
Nazis in Florida not being called out is a defense for folks not calling out "Go Back to Poland?"
shrike3
Apr 23
#75
Lots of genocide in the world. Guess there are those who are picking and choosing, too.
shrike3
Apr 23
#77
So the fact that protestors are being smeared is more important than antisemitic chants.
shrike3
Apr 23
#78
Okay, that's fair. As I've said in other posts, one can differentiate. Between the actions of a sovereign nation and
shrike3
Apr 23
#26
The usual way, though. There wasn't any blanket banning. People who refused to agree to the
betsuni
Apr 26
#98
How can you possibly expect people to judge you fairly when you refuse to define
Beastly Boy
Apr 23
#63
It goes the other way, too. Criticizing antisemitism is dismissed because, well, you know.
shrike3
Apr 23
#40
The organizer said they're not anti-Semitic. Case closed, I guess, nothing to see here, move along.
Jedi Guy
Apr 23
#28
According to her own students, does she not disagree with their assessments, or
Beastly Boy
Apr 23
#21
Are you saying that being a student at a college encampment makes you more informed and objective than
Beastly Boy
Apr 23
#31
The President of Colombia University - and any University - is beholden to money coming in.
haele
Apr 25
#91
What's going on is a whole lot of students who pay about $90,000 a year for the privilege, are
Vinca
Apr 23
#44
I Am a Jewish Student at Columbia. Don't Believe What You're Being Told About 'Campus Antisemitism'
Nanjeanne
Apr 23
#46
You wouldn't think being against innocent people being murdered whether Israeli or Palestinian would
Nanjeanne
Apr 23
#57
The people of Palestine? What are you talking about? I can't respond to until I have a clue what you
Nanjeanne
Apr 23
#62
Ok let's talk about what you think about these facts. If you want to discuss semantics over occupied
Nanjeanne
Apr 23
#66
I actually mentioned Rafah Crossing and how the border works and who has permission to,use it and how
Nanjeanne
Apr 24
#80
Have a good trip. Stay safe. Thanks for telling me so much about myself. Most laughs I've had on DU in long time
Nanjeanne
Apr 24
#86
Your questions are rather insulting but I'll respond. My uncle and aunt worked with Vivian Silver's
Nanjeanne
Apr 23
#68